To send the page, simply enter your friend’s name and e-mail address. Remember to include your own name and e-mail address as well, so that your friend knows who sent the page. You can also attach a comment if you wish, which will be included in the electronic message that your friend will receive.
- The Citizen Voices Team
Four Dynamic Windows Onto Europe
by Her Excellency Michaëlle Jean
I am about to set out on a new State visit, this time to Europe. At the request of Prime Minister Stephen Harper, my husband Jean-Daniel Lafond and I will be travelling to Hungary, Slovakia, the Czech Republic and Slovenia, accompanied by nine delegates representing various academic, cultural, institutional and social sectors. Four countries with which Canada has strong historic ties and thousands of whose nationals are now Canadian citizens. Four dynamic windows onto Europe, at the heart of the European Union. Four nations with which Canada wants to strengthen its bonds and pursue successful agreements.
In addition to the official program, protocol events and bilateral meetings, it is important to us that we open a dialogue with civil society, as we have always taken every opportunity to do. Bringing diplomacy back to the human level gives us a better understanding of the issues facing the countries we will be visiting and allows us to get to the heart of their realities. This will help us to build interesting and more productive bridges between our societies. The members of our delegation will greatly enrich these discussions with their perspectives and expertise. We made a point of assembling a very diverse team with a wide range of interests and backgrounds, young and old alike, from various regions across Canada.
We also believe in the importance of cultural diplomacy. The Art Matters forums that we will hold along the way promise to be lively. Just like the youth forums, which are also on the program, based on those we have organized across Canada, that will focus on the concerns, aspirations and initiatives of youth. During our visit, we will explore a number of issues, including the place of minorities, the integration of the Roma into society, the status of women, the fight against discrimination, the place that the arts and culture hold in the public sphere, governance, and opportunities for trade and cultural and institutional exchanges.
172 Comments
Thank you for your excellent work to date representing Canada.
The present political situation in Canada in our time of crisis is uncomfortable and as a citizen of Canada I am scared.
The present Conservative government has erred in trying to remove the financial support from political parties and in attempting to control civil servants. Hopefully they will recant their positions on both matters.
Regarding the present world financial crisis our duly elected Government is acting responsibly and the planning and action to date is correct. To act in isolation from our largest trading partner would be irresponsible and only serve to increase our national debt through unplanned actions.
I am hoping that you have a third option if the "coalition" approaches Your Excellency asking to govern Canada and that would be to give our present Government a one year mandate to prove themselves to the Canadian people.
Our politcal parties are hurting Canada's image and reputation through their grandstanding which is erroding our global financial situation resulting in further job losses in Canada.
Thank you for your consideration.
Yours truly,
Alan Reece
I think it is very undemocratic that a coalition government be allowed to be formed after a Conservative government was just elected with an increased mandate in these volatile economic times. This coalition proposal which may be presented to you if a confidence vote is held, does not represent the will of the Canadian people who such a short while ago gave the Torys an increased mandate to govern. The Liberals and the NDP combined have less votes than the Conservatives. Given that they would have to be supported by the Bloc Quebecois ( dedicated to the destruction of Canada)the coalition represents an undemocratic choice, and serious threat to the well being of and unity of Canada.
If the government should fall with a non confidence vote I request that a new election be called and the people be allowed to make their choice of who is to govern Canada.
Peter Kavanagh
Brampton Ont.
Michaëlle Governor General of Canada
I am writing to you today because I am very concerned and dismayed at the state of our beautiful country that is Canada. As I was browsing the Governor General website I notice that as part of your role and responsibilities, the Governor General promotes our national identity and unity. It made me think of the essay my son did last year in his grade 8 History course entitle Confederation. Here are some excerpts:
Confederation? Many of you may be asking what is it? It is sad that most people in our country don’t know what it is when it is one of the most important historical events in Canada’s history. So I will take you on a journey to the past. There you will learn why and how we got to call our country Canada.
You see back in the 1800’s Canada wasn’t one country. It was actually two separate provinces, Canada east and Canada west. These provinces are known today as Ontario and Quebec.
During the 1860’s the people in the colonies of British North America didn’t think of them as one nation. The colonies were very apart and in quiet different locations. They started to get concerned that the free trade with the US was coming to an end. The people started to think if they united British North America they could regain their economic prosperity back from the free trade with the US.
There were many reasons for confederation. Reasons why and how to make our country better. First, there was the political deadlock. In 1841 Canada east and Canada west each had equal number of seats in their joint legislative assembly. Because of this neither Canada east or west could set legislations. There were four parties in the untied province of Canada. There were two from Canada east and two from Canada west.
2nd is the railway linking the colonies. It was needed to increase trade and to move troops. At the time there were no railways linking the colonies. So this idea was very popular among the people and government.
3rd was the cancellation of the reciprocity treaty with the United States. Then they could limit the free trade between British North America and the United States. If they united they could trade products among each other with no tariffs (taxes).
The fourth reason is that the British were afraid that the Americans (US) would claim some of Canada’s land to expand there own country. The colonies thought if they were united they could defend themselves from this kind of threat. In the 1860’s north and South America fought against each other in the civil war. The southern raiders took control of some on the colonies in British North America to attack the northern American army from above. Because of this after the war the North Americans accused Canada for help the southern raiders. This made Canada more concerned of United States attack them. Eventually those fears came true. As in 1866 the Fenians, a group of Irish Catholics from the United States want the end British rule over Ireland. Of course, they could not reach Ireland so decided to attack there northern friends. The Fenians made several armed raids across the border in Canada.
The 5th reason is that Great Britain wanted her colonies to be more independent and self sufficient. Great Britain wanted to benefit from her northern American colonies.
The final reason is that some people wanted Canada to expand into the North West territories and Rupert land. Farmland in Canada west was blowing away; because of this if they expand Canada they will get farmland and other goods.
On may 22 1867 queen Victoria announced that the dominion of Canada be made.
Canada our country has gone through a lot of things. But how much do we appreciate the work and effort that some people did to make our country how it is today. Now that we answered the question of how our country got to how it is, another question pops up. What will happen to Canada in the future?
Which brings me to why I am writing to you today. Canada is from East to West and to the North. We are supposed to be a united entity comprised of different genders, ethnicities, religious beliefs, heritage but sharing a common ideal that is "We are 1 nation, Canada". The coalition proposed by the Liberals, NDP and Bloc Quebecois is completely opposite of this common ideal. To suggest that a coalition including the BLOC Qébecois that's main ideal is to separate from our country, to form their own nation which would mean the destruction of our country Canada as we know it is unthinkable. We just had an election which clearly stated a few important points:
First: If you take each party separately it clearly shows what Canadians want. A Conservative government with Stephen Harper as our Prime Minister. To include the Bloc Quebecois in the equation of the opposition does not clearly reflect what the Canadian voters want, as their sole intent is to separate from this country. Therefore, I personally do not include them as being part of the opposition. All you have left are the Liberals and NDP.
Second: The Canadian voters clearly demonstrated by having the lowest in history of Liberal seats elected that it did not want Stephane Dion as its Prime Minister. Therefore, to suggest that he should be the Prime Minister if this coalition happens is clearly against the choice of the Canadian voters.
I come from a very diverse family. I am part French Canadian born in the province of Quebec (I do not consider myself a Quebecois), part Aboriginal married to a second generation Italian immigrant. My son is married to a first generation Cambodian immigrant. I use to live in the Quebec province but got so tired and sicken by the politics in that province that I move to Ontario in 1989. My oldest brother did the same and moved to Nova Scotia many years ago. Don't take me wrong, I love the province of Quebec but I love my country Canada more. I still have family members living in the province of Quebec and to tell you the truth it is very sad that when we get together it always ends up in a lot of arguments and dividedness about Canada. I know that if it were possible my father would choose not to remain as he also doesn't like the Quebec politics, but I have a brother and sister living around Quebec city who have now become separatist and it saddens me as it has divided our family and I can just imagine what it is doing to our country.
I am asking you today to take everything in consideration when you made your decision, I know it is going to be a very difficult one but I trust in your wisdom that you will upheld the role and responsibility of your title to promote our national identity and unity. Canada is one Nation, one Country. Don't get swept into a legal loophole as this proposed coalition would have you believe. I trust in you and your judgment that you will do what is best of our country Canada. To quote my son Joe "
Canada our country has gone through a lot of things. But how much do we appreciate the work and effort that some people did to make our country how it is today. Now that we answered the question of how our country got to how it is, another question pops up. What will happen to Canada in the future?"
Yes, your Excellency, it is now up to you. Please save our country for me, my children, grandchild and all the Canadians families.
Regards,
Linda Paolozzi
Stittsville, Ontario
Please do everything within your power to prevent Stéphane Dion from becoming Prime Minister of Canada. Our Prime Minister should be voted in by Canadians,not hand picked from the 3+ parties that lost the election.
If the government should fall with a non confidence vote I request that a new election be called and the people be allowed to make their choice of who is to govern Canada.
Russell Sprunt
Toronto, Ont.
It is a wonderful thing to be able to post this note to you and I hope that you are able to take the time to hear what the people of Canada are asking of you. We have the democratic right to vote and that vote should be unbreakable. I have voted for many years with confidence that no matter who was elected, I had done my part in that decision making process. Now it seems, my vote and everyone elses in Canada can be changed if the losing parties do not approve. When I speak to younger people about this, they simply say - well then, what was the point of bothering to vote. We are not being given a chance to speak out about this - but this is our country - we pay the wages of all those "gentlepersons" in Parliament. We voted and that should either stand firm or we should have the right to vote again.
I am writing because I am deeply disturbed by the prospect of a Coalition Government. Canadians have just returned from the polls and have provided a mandate to a minority Conservative Government. The idea of a Coalition Government appears to be a grab for power and is a slight to democracy. This is not how politics should be handled in a country with such a rich history of democracy.
Should the government fall, I'm asking you to send Canadians back to the polls and allow us to choose our own government instead of having a government, without any mandate from Canadians, thrust upon us.
Thank-you,
Darren Milne
the Right Honourable Michaëlle Jean, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D.
Governor General of Canada
I am concerned about this coalition. If the government should fall with a non confidence vote I request that a new election be called and the people be allowed to make their choice of who is to govern Canada. I believe in our freedom to choose.
I too am concerned with the current state of our government. We did just have a federal election and made our voices heard as to whom we wanted to have govern us. In no way is it democratic to have a coalition form from 3 parties that were not voted into power, and let them govern the country. We did not vote for them and the liberal party does not even have a leader who is willing to stay on as a leader. Plus the Bloc doesn't even want to be a part of Canada. How can this even be considered to be a form of government? This act is obviously one of desperation and we cannot have our country ruled by desperate people. Please consider that we need to have the people of the country have their say and not leaders who have not been voted in. Thank you for your listening ear to one concerned voice in a wonderful country.
Lisa Hartley
Winnnipeg, MB
As I write this, it is becoming more evident and imperative that the Coalition government cannot be allowed to take form. The Liberals under Stephane Dion were soundly defeated in November. Having been handed their worst election result in a very long time, the thirteen million voters made it clear that they did not want Mr. Dion to represent our country.
To let that the proposed coalition government proceed with Mr. Dion or anyone else as Prime Minister, would be an injustice to the Canadian voters.
Karl Adam
Calgary Northwest
the Right Honourable Michaëlle Jean, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D.
Governor General of Canada
At a time when I am sure many Canadians forsee a potentially severe political crisis in Canadian federalism, I request you to act with your full authority. Clearly you know the issues. As our vicereine representative, and in consideration of how Canadians have recently voted, I ask you to do what you feel is the correct action for Canada, for Canadians, and in Her Majesty's best interests for OUR commonwealth realm.
Sincerely,
Donald A. S. Black
Rothesay, N.B.
I, along with others in this forum, would like to express my concerns about the recent creation of a coalition between the opposition members of this great nation.
I don't dispute the fact that the opposition parties represent the majority of the voters, but a vote for the NDP or Liberal parties were cast in the hopes of bettering this great nation. However, those votes were never cast knowing that the the NDP or the Liberals were going to be joining forces with the Bloc, a party dedicated to the separation of Quebec. This change in policy no longer allows the NDP or Liberals to represent the majority of voters, and I feel that this now makes the coalition undemocratic and unrepresentative of the majority of Canadians.
Also, the coalition would put into power a PM who Canadians wholeheartedly rejected in the last election and a man who's own party is ready to replace him. I feel it prudent to point out that in any other nation in the world, a leader who was not elected by the people is never recognized as it's true leader by other world bodies and disposed of eventually. It seems now, the coalition will stop at nothing to provide instability at a time when stability is what is needed most. Please ensure that democracy rules and prevent the coalition from obtaining power. If you have lost faith in the government to govern at this time, allow the electorate to make the decision on what to do now by a vote.
Sincerely,
Brad Gamroth
I am writing you as a concerned Canadian citizen. I along with many Canadians are facing layoffs if our current economical situation doesn't improve. I know this isn't something that can be fixed overnight but with all of our political issues going on it is only hindering our economy. Our Political party leaders are more concerned about getting the Conservatives out of power then working on our current situation. So I ask you...no beg you to please put a stop to this madness and lets get our economy back on top. If all the leaders worked together we could achieve this goal. We have to for all of Canada's sake.
I would rather cast another vote.
People of Canada do not come out to vote because they feel the government will do what ever it wants anyway. This will reinforce this attitude, and ultimately lead to anarchy..
We must at all costs bring the democratic system back into place and bring stability to the government process.
If need be even though we are in the midst of economic upheaval and the cost of an election is enormaus it may be the only way to stabize this government.
God help us all
It distresses me to find out that here is the possibility shortly that my vote will count for nothing. We talk often in this country about low voter turnout, and what better way to discourage people from voting, if the very man who was most soundly thrashed in the past election, is allowed to take the reins of power. Those in favour of the new coalition say that the majority did not elect the conservatives, but please, please remember, when they come to you, that NOBODY voted for the coalition. That they must rely on the very party who wants to destroy our country (and, in my opinion, should not even be eligble for a federal party) and who has never recieved a vote west of Quebec makes me ill. If you accept this co-alition government, all it will suceed in doing is to make us a laughing stock and put us on the same level as those countries where military coups and often staged. The proper thing to do would be to call an election and make the coalition run as a coalition (which I doubt they would be willing to do- ironic isn't it?) - then let Canadians show what we really think.
Sincerly,
Judy
I am most grateful that I can communicate with you and your office in this manner. The relationship between all levels of our government and its citizens is very important to me, as I trust it is to you. When you were installed as Governor-General, I found your motto of 'Breaking down barriers' most encouraging, hence this communication.
On October 16, 2008, you made a Speech from the Throne on behalf of the Conservative Party and its leader, Mr. Stephen Harper. In the first major section of Mr. Harper's part of that text, titled "Strong Leadership. A Better Canada", third paragraph, he said, "Canadians expect their government to help them build on this legacy. They want a government that sets clear goals and delivers concrete results. A government that is accountable. A government that puts Canadians and their families first." When you made that speech, there had already been many indications of the global economic downturn and there have been many more since.
The recent 'Economic update' by FInance Minister Flaherty ignored the observable facts, making conditional statement after conditional statement, vaguely promising much, yet saying nothing significant to address the serious challenges faced by Canadians across this country. I was a teacher before my retirement. If Mr. Flaherty had been one of my pupils, I would have thought that either he didn't care about the economic reality facing the country, or that he had come to class unprepared. He had nothing to say that reassures the 350,000 - 400,000 people in Ontario whose livelihood depends upon the auto sector, for example. Nor had he anything to say to the workers in the forest industry, nor the thousands of others across this country who will be effected by the change in the economy. To finish his speech with an assault on democratic rights, rights gained by women and government employees over time, and to attempt to utterly destroy Her Majesties Loyal Opposition by removing the meagre public funding the ll parties receive, was an unconscionable act of arrogant indifference.
I judge people by what they do, as well as by what they say. I take Mr. Harper at his word. He has patently failed to meet the expectations he asked you to make on his behalf in the Speech from the Throne and should suffer the political consequences. If a vote of non-confidence is made, and the government falls, it is within your purview to allow someone else to seek the confidence of the majority of a members of the House. It is constitutional and legal to do so; there is precedent for it. It would only be even more irresponsible to prorogue Parliament to an even later date, putting the needs of the country in greater peril and its citizens in greater distress.
Please be so kind to remind Mr. Harper of his own words when you meet with him and to ask him if he has passed or failed his own test.
With my greatest respect,
Graham Fawcett,
Greely, ON
Please remember that, when all that stands for is now threatened.
Hit the streets and protest if we must!
Joe Landry
Canada's democracy is not a role model to Canadians let alone the world as a result of this political fiasco. When the world's worst economic meltdown is about to unfold, we see 3 leaders irresponsibly pushing the citizen into another election.
Here's what I see : Budget not up to expectation
Here's what opposition should do : Reject the budget presented by the minority government. END OF STORY !!
Instead, they chose to have a marriage of convenience to "select" among themselves the biggest loser in history to run this country.
I have no problem with Mr. Dion being the PM as long as it's the people's choice. The only way to know that is by way of another election.
By giving Mr. Dion a chance to be PM by way of coalition formed immediately after an election, means that I am not motivated to vote again because in the next election, all the opposition needs to do is form a coalition with, say, a 2-year agreement. THAT'S IT !!.
As a citizen who voted in the rain with the hassle of 2 kids tagging along, I want to know :
1. Why can't they just "REJECT THE PROPOSED BUDGET"?
2. Does it mean everytime a budget that (assumed) doesn't work, requires a new PM or election?
3. Why are they not taking the role of a true leader by coming up with a good reject-and-propose budget just like any great country should be?
4. I have seen how disoriented they were during the debate prior to election and suddenly they are "married"?
5. How does a $30 billion budget rescue the automakers. All I see is taxpayers money paying for CEO's salary to keep the company producing trucks which nobody buys. Every industry is going to grab the $30 billion. Where will the bailout ends?
6. How does a $30 billion package (2.5% of our $1.2 trillion economy) going to make a difference. If there isn't, why bother us for another election?
7. How does a few thousand lay-offs in automaker industry affect 18 million labour force?
8. How can we be sure that this $30 billion package (bailout) is not going to be a precedence of "It's OK to be a lakadaisical and sink the company" attitude?
Your Excellency
the Right Honourable Michealle Jean,
Governor General of Canada.
Excellency,
It is with deep concern that I write you regarding the turmoil within our Canadian Parliament.
Given the fact that the present government, duly elected and accepted by the Canadian population, is facing certain defeat in a vote of "no confidence" I urge you to consider the voice of that population by installing a caretaker government; this caretaker government to remain in place until such time as an election is able to be held.
Precedent for this course of action, in our system of democracy, was set in Australia in the mid 1970's.
If this were to eventuate the new "coalition" could face the people as exactly that and the electorate at large would be in a position to vote for the group of their choice based upon the stated positions of the parties.
A majority would ensue,it would be one chosen by the people and democracy would have prevailed.
Yours faithfully,
Phillip Grimison
Calgary.
I am writing to concur with the previous comments posted here over the past couple of days. I understand that you are cutting your trip short so that you can address the political issues that have arisen this week in our country.
I am quite unsettled by the proposal that the three opposition parties have put forward in wanting to take over governing our country. This is in opposition to what we, the people of this country, just finished voting on, and I am at my wits end trying to find out why we, as the people of this country, can't have an official say as to whether this is what we want!
I find it amazing that we will be headed by a group of people who received such a low vote just one month ago, including a party who is only representing one province and has only one agenda in mind.
Please do what you can to ensure that this "coup" does not happen!
Lisa Catallo
As one of the majority of Canadians who voted for one of the coalition parties, I am glad to see that the three parties are united today for the good of Canada. I would be disappointed if a minority government shuts down the parliament just to hang on to power when it loses confidence of the House who represents the majority of Canadians.
Kindest regards,
Oshawa, Ontario
I am saddened, by this mess in Ottawa. We are a democratic society, why should the opposition parties who have not been given power by Canadians, have the right to form a coalition government. If Canadians would have wanted any of those parties in power we would have voted that way. Why should a person who is not even wanted as a leader for his political party be allowed to serve as Prime Minister. we spend Millions of tax dollars on trying to get voters out to the poles to have a say. We tell them it's your civil right to vote and have a say in the government of Canada. This coalition government is saying and showing to all Canadians your opinions don't matter. Your vote is useless and doesn't count, you don't have a say. So I ask why bother if the parties are able to do as they want any way. I ask that you do not allow the coalition government to form. I would rather see another election then this NDP/Bloc/Liberal non sense in power.
thank You !
Philip Cyr
Richmondhill
First of all, while it is not for me to apologize on behalf of the country, I do apologize for the interruption of this most worthwhile endeavor. Indeed I and many other citizens are embarrassed by this silliness from our politicians and its personal effect on your work on our behalf.
In the name of national unity, I suggest to you we will need to go back to the polls. If indeed you are required to consider a Coalition Government, such as has been suggested, it will not work. The country will bicker and fight and I fear for even more alienation of not only parts of the country but also citizens in our belief in Canadian democratic institutions, including yours.
Trust in the good sense of the Canadian people to work through this unfortunate dilemma that we may have forced upon you. Unfortunately an election now will provide a solution sooner rather than later. What has been suggested by this coalition will be fought in any case until an election is called. Lets call it now and get it over with ... again.
With heartfelt best wishes to you and yours from my family.
Re: Support for the Proposed Coalition Government
I urge you to ask the Liberal, NDP and Bloc parties to form a government and to govern according to the formal coalition to which they have committed. I further urge you to ask this coalition to govern regardless of the entreaties, arguments and questionable precedents which will be offered by Mr. Harper to allow him to cling to power for much longer. At this time of dire economic conditions, Canadians need the stability which the coalition will provide and which Mr. Harper has spurned.
Of course you will make the best decision on behalf of all Canadians, informed by your constitutional experts. I am confident that whatever decision that you render that it will be the correct one and I will support it and you. I hope that this statement is not presumptuous but in this time of fractious public debate it is important to make such a declaration, remembering the long term stability and continuity that our institutions provide.
This cuts to the heart of the existing situation. The leader of the Conservative party has created significant instability in parliament, in society and in our economy when, in this time of great economic and personal uncertainty, he should be doing the very opposite. He should have been governing on behalf of all Canadians instead of seeking partisan, personal and ideological advantage. In this divided House of Commons, elected recently by the people of Canada, he should have been seeking to work with the other parties to create a stable, functioning government. He did the opposite.
Mr. Harper has demonstrated appalling stewardship in such a manner as to indicate clearly that he is unfit to be the Prime Minister of Canada. He will never again enjoy the trust of neither parliamentarians nor Canadians, even in his own party, from coast to coast to coast.
In four days, the opposition parties have brought to parliament the multi-year stability that Mr. Harper refused to do. This coalition government will work, if not perfectly, certainly vastly superior to the ongoing chaos and acrimony that would have endured under Mr. Harper. Furthermore, through the ballot box, this coalition enjoys the support of 65% of the electorate, nearly double that obtained by the Conservatives. The majority of elected parliamentarians have agreed to advance a legislative program which they will all support, bringing to the debates not only their rich differences but also a trust of the “other” manifest by their mutual trust and respect and their shared enthusiasm for constructively advancing leadership and legislation on behalf of all Canadians.
The coalition presents not only an effective resolution of this crisis but it is also an example to all Canadians and to the world of Canadian fundamental decency, common sense, and respect for the “other”.
It looks like a crisis, but something magnificent is rising from these ashes.
I wish you equanimity and peace during your deliberations.
Sincerely,
Ian McCallum
I hope that the current crisis will demonstrate to all Canadians the value of their constitutional monarchy. The role of the Queen, as represented by yourself, is to keep the politicians honest. You could do worse than ask HM's advice, since she has a lot of experience in constitutional matters.
Regarding the immanent decision that will be expected of you in the very near future, I would like to strongly suggest that you consider proroguing the House until the government presents its budget on January 27th. Its not that I nessarily think that the Harper government deserves a break; I believe they incited what appears to be a retaliatory reaction from the Opposition. I'm dismayed by the immaturity being displayed by our political leadership at this critical time when we should have their collective focus and attention directed toward governing the country. The Coalition alternative seems a very weak one and fraught with uncertainty and peril. It seems to me that the Prime Minister is probably by now repentant of his antics and as such, in our country's best interest and in the absence of a viable alternative, a decision of prorogation is worthy a trial of restitution. If the government and opposition continues to weigh favour toward playing political games rather than governing as the peoples' voice has recently directed, then I would suggest you allow a new election. Despite the formidable cost in dollars and sense at this critical time, I think that such a decision, in light of the bizarre alternative, would be strategically appropriate for us, the people, where I'm sure the collective wisdom will speak strongly and create a hopefully more viable governing body. To allow the Coalition, as it appears, would it seems create further short term chaos or potentially plunge our country deeply into an economic black hole.
Respectfully,
John Pellizzon
Kamloops, BC
I support a LIB/NDP/BLOC coalition.
Do not order a new election. When the people of Canada voted to maintain the status quo on October 14, 2008 they told the parliamentarians that they wanted the government to learn to work together. What ever party or group of parties that make a majority of parliamentarians should represent the people of Canada. Unfortunately the government does not have the support of the house but the majority of the house does support an alternative. The majority of parliamentarians are looking to work together and they should be allowed to be our voice. It has been a dream of many citizens to finally see parties working together, please allow them to do so.
Another election would be bad for Canada. We would most likely vote roughly the same members into parliament, but it would discourage Canadians from participating again. We just had an election with incredibly low voter turn out and we can't afford to have more Canadians not voting, it would be a disaster for our democratic system.
Please do not dissolve parliament. Allow the Liberal/NDP/BLOC coalition to work together.
Paolo Raponi
Toronto, Canada
the Right Honourable Michaëlle Jean, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D.
Governor General of Canada
It appears that the present government will soon be defeated by a non-confidence vote. It will be your decision then, apparently, to decide to dissolve the present parliament and call a general election to elect a new government, or to allow a coalition of minority opposition parties to form a new goverment.
You should consider this matter very carefully with respect to the laws and constitution of our country and make your decision with prudence and due consideration of what is best for Canadians.
As a Canadian, I say that the government of Canada should be elected by Canadian voters, not replaced by a coalition of minority opposition parties whose leaders and election platforms were rejected in the previous election. Yes, the present government can be defeated by a coalition of minority party votes, but the coalition should not be placed in power as a result of their vote.
In your decision, please favor calling an election to allow Canadian voters to elect the new government. We Canadians should decide who will govern us.
Sincerely,
Bob Feindel
I too am writing to protest this coalition. For all of the above reasons plus one of my own. I received an email today which I have been assured is a true conference call of the NDP. In my books this call is treasonous and should be looked at very carefully by you. The people have voted and we do not want the likes of Jack Layton or Stefan Dion running OUR country. Thank you.
If this coalition does succeed in overthrowing our rightfully elected government, I call on you to call a new election as it represents the only democratic fix to this unconscionable situation. All Canadians, regardless of which party they supported in the very recent election must be allowed a say. I believe all Canadians deserve to vote with full knowlege of what this coalition intends to bring to table with all details of any and all conscession made clear to all. Nobody voted for their platform in it's current form, not even their own constituents. Please ensure that we in Canada continue in the finest democratic tradition.
Michelle DeCosse
I also am writing this with deepening concern over the political unrest that is occuring as we speak in our beloved Canada.
The coalition that has been forming in an effort to defeat a government that was rightfully elected by Canadians a short time ago is a recipe for disaster.
As I understand the situation, their forming must be approved by you as Governor General. I hope you will understand and agree with the people of Canada that democracy is the way of the Canadian people, not back-hand politics.
I agree with the other posts here today ~ to let this coalition procees would be an injustice to Canadians at large.
Laurel Diprose
Wetaskiwin, Alberta
I am very disturbed that the three opposition party leaders can hijack our recent election under the pretext of no stimulus package at this time.
The government promised a budget in January with a stimulus package. If the opposition brings down the government please do not allow this coalition to go ahead. Please call an election or pirogue parliament so that we can see the new budget and stimulus package in January. If the opposition still brings down the government then please call an election so that we the voters of Canada can have the last word.
Richard Dubber
Saskatoon SK
My wife and I are enthralled by the political drama that is unfolding before us, the centre stage being Parliament. After an election in which one of the participants promised to play nice and not kick sand in the face of the underdog, we have a new parliament. Once again sand was kicked in the form of an empty economic package, except for the negatives: the right to strike being removed from your civil servants, the right to pay equity and the right to have political funding from the public purse. Each is an irritant and the whole has caused the opposition to rise as one and say 'enough'.
I believe that the present government has lost the confidence of the house and as such, should be asked to step down. The leader of the opposition should then be asked to form the government and if that involves the opposition aligning itself with other parties in a coalition, then so be it. There are enough checks and balances within our system that their governance will not stray too far from Canada's rightful path. Perhaps the two major parties in this coalition may come to an agreement to permanently form a socially conscious party in opposition to the present governing party, which itself was a coalition of two right wing parties.
We do not fear the Bloc party and their separatist intentions but rather welcome them into the fold in the hope that eventually they recognise that the country is stronger as a whole with recognition of its individual parts.
David Lobban
Winnipeg
the Right Honourable Michaëlle Jean, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D.
Governor General of Canada
It is with a great hope that I write you today and ask for your aid in protecting democracy in Canada. When this Federal minority government falls, I beg you to help our nation by choosing to force a new election. It falls to you to act in the defense of our nation's sovereignty and prevent our country from fragmenting. The opposition leader may have devised a way gain the "confidence" of parliment, but it should be clear by now that parliment has lost all the confidence of the citizens of Canada. We have been failed by ALL the party leaders and I ask for the right to tell them that, by the only means I have...my vote.
Our brave soldiers past and present have risked and are risking their lives in defense of our freedom, and the least we can do is defend our freedoms at home, even if it means we need an election every two months for a year until parliment gets the message.
Your Loyal Citizen,
Mark Hintermann
Ottawa,ON
If the government should fall with a non confidence vote, please allow for a new election to be called. The people of Canada did not choose to elect the Liberal or the NDP parties. We chose to elect the Conservative party and I think that if we must do it over again, we will surely get it right. I believe that we need to have a government with the support of the people, and the people did not choose to have Stéphane Dion as prime minister of Canada
As a very faithful Canadian I beg you to do something. When we went to the polls not so long ago we as the people spoke. We live in a democratic society and it should be the people who decide who their government is and it shouldn't be decided behind closed doors. I don't believe for a moment that this wasn't planned a long time ago. I believe that this government has proven themselves enough to deserve a chance to show us what they can do during this very difficult time. I believe that if we allow this to happen it will destabilize our economy even further. Something we simply can't afford. Don't let the bullies win! We didn't elect them and they shouldn't be able to ban together and take over the government when they haven't earned that right. For the first time in my life I'm feeling afraid to be Canadian. Please stop the madness!
I am also writing to express my concern with respect to the "Coalition". This cannot be allowed to proceed any further. The Liberal Party and the NDP Party combined do not have enough seats to defeat the Conservative Party, so they have had to make promises to Mr. Duceppe. What kind of deal did this coalition make with Gilles Duceppe in order to buy his support? Please do not allow this to continue. If Mr. Layton and Mr. Dion feel that Canada wants what they are trying to force upon it, call for a new election and let all Canadians decide.
Thank you for the great work you are doing for Canada.
At this unique moment in Canadian history you hold in your hands the future of democracy in Canada. Canadians turned to you as the only person who can prevent the descent of their country to the ranks of a Banana Republic, by denying the coalition a chance to form a new government. Furthermore, a coalition government that usually represents political instability, in this time of the great economical uncertainty will send the country into a deep recession.
Just 6 weeks ago Canadians re-elected Conservative government giving them a stronger mandate than before.
Apparently, the other three parties who lost elections instantly started to plot a coup, long before there even had been a reason for a non-confidence in the duly re-elected government.
If you allow the coup to happen this country will never be the same politically and economically.
Your Excellency, it is in your power to either call another election or to extend the mandate of the existing government so they can prove Canadians that a reason for a coup was invented by the opposition in an attempt of a power grab.
Recognizing the magnitude of the cost of new elections, the frustration of voters who were at the polls just 6 weeks ago, this option nevertheless will bring to power either re-elected once again current government or will it transfer power to another party but in a truly democratic fashion.
Please, do not submit to a false feeling of loyalty to Liberals just because they offered you’re your position. We rely on you to stand firm protecting democracy in Canada, even if it involves hard choices and difficult decisions.
respectfully,
nina triger
I am also joining the others to express my deep concern with the current state of our government. I took the time to vote and would appreciate if it actually meant something. I fear that the turmoil the losing parties are creating will only worsen the state of our economy. If a coalition occurs I may never vote again! Why should I? Apprently it means nothing! I'm so mad and somehow feel personally attacked. It is time for you to come home and deal with this mess. If a coalition occurs I will no longer be a proud Canadian. Words I never thought I would hear myself say.
Regards,
Sue
As a registered voter (just like you are) I sincerely hope that you will restore my faith in the democratic process by denying this self-serving coalition. There is a fundamental principle here that must override all other considerations: the voice of the people must be heard! The current government was voted in by that collective voice;
this coalition seeks to overthrow that voice. Please either endorse our current,duly-elected government, or allow the Canadian people to choose whom they would have to lead them. Please don't allow a government coup to happen in Canada.
In this global economic crisis, Canada and Canadians need a government with a sound economic plan and a singular mandate...Keep Canada strong and stable in a time of turmoil. The Coalition does not share a singular view or understanding on how to keep Canada strong, prosperous, and a global leader. We as Canadians told Parliament less than two months ago what we wanted. We have not changed our minds and do not want a Coalition Party. Allowing the Coalition to govern would strip Canadian citizens of our democratic rights. The Accord put forth by this new Coalition will only prove to damage Canada. Please do not sign the accord and leave Canada at the mercy of an unknown, unproven, untrustworthy entity.
Sincerly,
Jennifer Silliman
I am concerned with the state of affairs in our country at this time. It is imperative that political gamesmanship be eliminated from the equation from all sides of the House. While our country is economically much better off then our neighbours the condition is fragile and the upheaval brought about by the poor judgement of the Prime Minister and exacerbated by the coalition led by Mr. Dion are making things worse. I believe that it is incumbent on you to calm the waters and find a solution that is both meaningful and democratic. The electorate has spoken only 6 weeks ago and their decision should be respected. The Prime Minister has backed down from his position which appeared to incent the opposition so the matter should be laid to rest and the governance of the country should be continued until the voters make their own choice.
I thank you for the privilege to be able to address you and also thank you for the wonderfaul manner in which you have undertaken your responsibilities.
Respectively, Allan Garber
I have voted both Liberal and Conservative as I saw fit at the time and for whichever party had the best interests of Canadians at heart. This proposed coalition by definition cannot possibly serve the broad interests of Canadians as it depends on a separatist party to remain in power. The leader of this proposed coalition has already lost the confidence of Canadians, as demonstrated by the recent election results, and he proposes to resign anyway at his party's next leadership convention. Whilst I was very disappointed that our prime minister chose to include peripheral, non core issues in the fiscal update, this is not the time to invite political chaos on top of a global economic crisis that threatens our very well being. Please find a way to send these children, of all parties, back to work and start governing as adults.
I am a small voice that has never publically spoken out until today.
I think that allowing this coalition to take leadership of our country is a huge mistake. Their reasons for trying to oust the current government has the smell of a rat and this rat should be squashed.
I think that if anyone or group has made a mistake, they should be given time to correct the mistake, and also, I would not like to see another election at this time; if the current government must be removed, the new one should be voted in.
Regardless of my being a devout Liberal, I am writing to you to ask you on behalf of Canadian citizens across the land to NOT allow this take-over by the proposed 'coalition'.In fact I would like to see Dion removed from office, We didn't vote him in, and we showed we don't want him. As much as I disagree with Harper's platform. I believe in being a fair loser. The Liberal party needs a huge restructure.
Justin W
Vancouver, BC
Along with my family and friends, I was feeling very confused and angry about the possibility that my last federal vote didn't matter but moreso that we all may be facing a coalition government as early as next week. What has happened to our common goals and our common sense? Somebody is not thinking about the big picture, just their own personal power-based agendas. I am sick of it and the people who are behind this kind of stupid behavior and you know who they are. Enough about how I felt this morning. This afternoon, after logging onto your blog and reading the very sensitive and articulate comments from my fellow canadians and how they along with themselves are looking to you to solve this ridiculous current political situation. Thanks to all for sending in your comments, please keep it up and continue to encourage eachother to do the right thing and maybe, just maybe our messages will get to the people who need it the most. My personal position would be to leave it as status quo or so to another federal election asap.
Please send us back to the poles and let the people speak...
Thanks
Mark Petursson
Thank you for taking the time to hear our concerns regarding the Coalition Government. As you can see by the majority of postings that Canadians are very concerned at loosing their democratic rights as laid out in the Charter of Rights. Our freedom (defined as the power to act without unfair interference by an individual or the state) is being compromised with this coupe being undertaken by the Liberal, NDP and Bloc Quebecois parties. What good is our right to vote if it can be denounced and overriden at the first sign of disagreement?
I can't understand why the political parties would use a loss of campaigning funds as a reason to "overthrow" the government. In times such as these, cutting back on this type of expenses and letting the parties raise their own funds (similar to the US) seems logical and fair. It isn't the political parties that need finacial help but those looking to feed their families and keep their jobs. With the communist view government that wants to take over, even those provinces that are sustaining their economic situations will crash with the "promised" Carbon Tax to be enacted. If you take away from the provinces that are managing to keep afloat, what good will the equalization payments be?
Please use your best judgement in making decisions that will effect ALL Canadians. Unfortunately, there seems to be a schism between the East and West, which leads to great difficulty in devising a compromise that is beneficial to all.
I voted Conservative for the first time in the recent election. I have been happy with Harper's performance both as a leader and with the economy. The Liberals did not earn my vote with a weak platform and an even weaker leader. The opposition claim they have the support of the majority of Canadians in their coup attempt. Only a fool would have voted for a coalition government that included Bloc Separatists on the team. The only time I would consider supporting Jack Layton would be in a return to municipal politics. My aging parents are so upset about this attempted coup that I fear for their health. Please reject the opposition's bid to return to power. Cooperation not coalition! If the opposition can't cooperate with the Conservatives then send us back to the polls and we will give the Conservatives the majority they need. I have expressed these opinions to both my MP Dr. Gary Goodyear and the Liberal party of Canada.
La crise politique actuelle est très inquiétante pour tous les Canadiens d'un océan à l'autre surtout, considérant la situation économique actuelle. A la suite des dernières élections, il fut entendu par tous les Partis que tous travailleraient ensemble pour le bon fonctionnement du Parlement. D'aucuns est innocent de partisannerie toutefois, ce sont tous les citoyens canadiens qui devront "souffrir" de ces irresponsabilités volontaires de la part de tous nos représentants.
Il demeure qu'une coalition fut formée par les deux Partis d'opposition avec le support du Bloc souverainiste, afin de forçer l'implantation d'un Premier ministre (Stéphane Dion-PLC) qui n'a pas obtenu la confiance de tous les Canadiens et Québécois lors de la dernière élection.
Votre Majesté, je vous supplis en tant que citoyenne Canadienne, de ne pas reconnaître cette coallition qui fait FI, de la démocratie canadienne. Si M. Dion veut le pouvoir à Ottawa, qu'il l'obtienne par la voie des suffrages telle que la démocratie requiert. Respectueusement,
Mme Lorraine Lamoureux
the Right Honourable Michaëlle Jean, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D.
Governor General of Canada
Your Excellency,
I am encouraged that so many Canadians have taken the time to write to you expressing their opinions regarding the proposed coalition government. Since becoming 18 years of age (I'm now 49!)I have always valued my democratic right to vote for the person who I think should become Prime Minister of Canada. I have not missed an opportuntity to vote in the past.
However, I am very disheartened that our democratic process in Canada may be jeopardized by people in political parties who didn't win in the last election. Each party is distinctly different and represent very different views-especially the Bloc who don't even believe in a united Canada!! I fail to see how three of these parties can suddenly put all their differences aside now and get along with one another to overthrow the Conservatives. It appears to be three big egos, hungry for power. They may appear to be working together at the moment, but for what purpose...I would suggest that it is for their own purposes and that they are not acting in the best interests of all Canadians. If they can work with one another, why can't they work with the Conservatives in order to put the best interests of Canadian citizens FIRST!
We just spent over 30 million dollars on the last election...which will be money wasted if the party who won can simply be overthrown by members of opposing parties. I would be shocked if you allowed another election to take place costing Canadians another 30 million dollars! In times of such economic crisis, this money could be spent so much more wisely. If you allow the coalition to take power, our democratic process will be destroyed...voter turnout was low in the last election and my prediction will be that if the coalition is allowed to take over, voter turnout will be even lower next time. I know that I won't vote ever again if Dion and his pals are allowed to overthrow the government.
I am a teacher and I visited a session in Parliament...to be honest, I was appalled at what I saw! The behavior of the members of Parliament would not have been acceptable in any Canadian classroom!! We work hard to teach our students how to act responsibly and respectfully...it is disheartening to see inappropriate behavior exhibited by our elected officials-people who all Canadians should be able to look up to and repect. We also spend a great deal of time teaching young people the importance of teamwork! I think that it is time that our elected politicians grow up and start working together for the good of all Canadians.
You have a great deal of power in this situation and I hope that you will reject the coalition attempt and tell each party to begin working together. In the end, if Canadians are not happy, we will have our say in the next, regularly scheduled, election.
Thank you for doing such a great job for our country.
Laurie
Vancouver, BC
As a Canadian citizen I am very concerned with the continuous attempts of the current Prime Minister Stephen Harper to undermine democracy in Canada. I have had enough of Mr. Harpers bullying tactics which have nothing to do with running this country. I would much prefer to see a leader who demonstrates the will to work with other members of parliament rather than a leader who seeks to control everyone and everything around him/her. Although there appear to be many people who suggest that the coalition is merely a means of defeating the conservative government I feel that this has more to do with the leadership abilities of Mr. Harper. Regardless of who anyone has voted for in the last election it is very important to have a funcitioning parliament. That being said the coalition which has been assembled by the Liberal, New Democrats, and Bloc parties illustrates what can be achieved when people want to work together. I personally recommend that the governor generals office endorse this new partnership as it is by far a better option than what is currently in place. I would also like you to look at the example that President Elect Baroc Obama has given by including Hillary Clinton in his future government. Working together is by far a better way forward for Canada and may also serve to connect Canadians like never before.
This was the voice of the Canadian people in a freely held open and transparent election.
To see the clear losers in a democratic election taking the constitutionally unprecidented step of forming a coalition, which has fewer total seats (excluding the Bloc) than the current government, with the intention of taking over government despite the electoral results is, to me, a clear attempt to bypass the electoral process.
I urge you to consider the clear wishes of the Canadian people and work with Mr. Harper and the Conservative power to permit them siufficient time to address the current economic crisis in an orderly fashion by either proroguing Parliament if so requested to allow time for such orderly consideration or, if confronted with a confidence issue, to dissolve parliamnet and begin the electoral process anew.
I to am very concerned about the direction the opposition parties are trying to force upon this great Nation of ours. It is imperative that the recently elected government be allowed to continue or parliament should be dissolved and the people once again be sent back to the polls. Noone should be allowed to usurp the operation of a legally elected government. This borders on treason!.
In addition, I am sure our trading partners are wondering who is in charge of this Country. Are we in fact safe as an investment vehicle!
This situation needs to be stabilized and quickly. Please, above all, do not let the opposition parties suceed with this coup d'etat.
I read here many voices opposed to coalition government, and I feel it is important to put forward an alternate view of these events.
One of the greatest strengths of the Canadian parliamentary system of government, from time to time, is the ability of minority parties to gain the balance of power in minority situations. Our history has shown clearly that it is precisely this mechanism which has made Canada one of the top countries in the world.
Through the focus of minority government, minority parties are able to bring forth and address issues which may not be important to all Canadians, yet are often of critical importance to some Canadians... Canadians who might otherwise never achieve representation on the national scene. Many of our most important, most renowned and most cherished policies have emerged from just such a crucible.
There can be no doubt that at times the tyranny of the majority has uses, and it is also true that at other times the strength of coalition has equal merit. The primary concern of coalition being the need for maintaining agreement in order to maintain power, has long served as the means for the achievement of real and needed reform. This pattern holds true in all democratic nations.
Indeed, it is this very ability of the minority to be heard, from time to time, which strengthens and binds our amazing country together. It is the essential core value that underlies the strength of all the Western powers, and thus far, is the ultimate achievement of any form of government. It is through this minority voice that Canadians know, even if they personally will never hold with a majority of the opinion, that occasionally even they will be heard.
I am only one Canadian, and I have only one voice, and with that voice I ask you to please consider this viewpoint carefully when you are making your decision.
Most Sincerely,
Eric R, Berglund.
Burlngton, Ontario.
I along with all the others are writing you to express my concerns with the latest developments in parliament. I vote at every election. I did not vote for the Conservatives therefore I did not vote for Prime Minister Harper. I did not vote for the Liberals or the NDP or Block either. I am therefore writing this being completely unbiased as I have no affection for any of the major parties.
Having said this I must emplore you not to allow this coalition. If we must go back to the poles then that is what we must do. If any of the opposition parties were truly concerned about our economy they would not be trying to further their own political agendas and seeking to steel power the people of Canada did not give them in the first place. This action in itself will have a negative effect on our markets and like every Canadian we have all ready lost enough money.
Canadian's as a whole voted in a minority Conservitive government because as a whole this is what we thought would serve our interests. There is a reason the Conservatives did not get a majority just as there is a reason the opposition was not voted in.
Please do not allow the opposition to highjack our right to vote. Maybe we could have a referrendum on the issues being put forth rather than letting parliment decide on it. Let the people decide not a group of men who seek power and notoriety. If this is not a possibility and there is no way to force them to get along and work in our (the people's) best interests then send us back to the poles. There are more than enough angry Canadians that I am sure will vote to put an end to the foolishness and even though it is not what we (the people) want we will probably give Prime Minister Harper the majority he has been after. At the very least the issue will be in the hands of the Canadian people where it belongs.
I would like to express my total disagreement with the coalition forming the next government. We didn't vote for a coalition. Should the conservative government fall, new elections should be called.
Sincerely,
Marhta & Ricardo Gerdingh
Kincardine, Ontario
I would like to express my concerns about the recent creation of a coalition between the opposition members of this great nation. I am pretty dispute to see that the Liberals and NDP and the Bloc can overthrown our Government without being formally elected to be Prime Minister. I thought we are living in a democratic country; however, from what is currently happened to our Government, it certainly doesn’t feel like so. What is the point of voting when the losing parties can easily change or ignore our choice of the previous election?
If the government should ever fall, I request that a new election be called so that our voices can be clearly heard.
Sincerely,
Amy Tan
Operating a small business in B.C. is not a piece of cake, but when I saw those bunch of yahoos Dion Layton and Ducette laughing and joking and behaving like schoolboys I was disgusted. Stephen Harper was elected by Canadians to serve Canadians and he has carried out his Oath of Office in an exemplary way. Let him proceed with his mandate and give him and his Ministers all the support that you can. As for that parcel of rogues...Their infamy will go down in history, which is their just desserts
I have always been very proud to be a Canadian but the events that took place yesterday have left me very sad.The backroom deals that took place with the losing parties of our recent democratic election leading up to a coup of our present government makes me feel like I am living in a third world country. Why would you expect us to trust them - especially the Bloc leader-? What world leader is going to have any faith in our government and want to do business with our country?
I do not envy your position but once again I beg you to do what is right for our country and not for what a bunch of sore losers want.
I too wish to express my deep concern reagarding the ecent coalition agreement.
I am on pension and have watched my few investments drop significantly in a remarkably short period of time. I live in NW Ontario where resource based industries, especially forestry, in decline because of the collapse of their United States markets, are almost non-existent after at least 5 years of deterioration. Here we’ve been in recession for some time. I volunteer at a food bank where the lineup of hungry neighbours increases each week with working poor as well as unemployed persons and understand that forty percent of those fed are children. Indeed the only positive developments I can see where I live are infrastructure related. And these endeavours took some time to negotiate and carry out. I don’t blame the Canadian government for this downturn; in fact, Canada is in better shape than most countries. Recently I voted in the federal election in the hopes that my ballot, along with those of many others, would ensure a democratically elected government to steer Canadians through these hard times.
I strongly doubt that mega company bailouts, strikes (in whatever sector), and this past week’s reported and continuing political intrigue and opportunistic, self-interest scheming will do anything to bolster Canada’s economy and worldwide reputation. In fact, I am shocked and upset that the NDP seems to have aligned with the separatist Bloc and then joined members of the Liberal party in an attempt to unseat the government in coup-like fashion.
I believe our parliamentary representatives should focus on the job we elected them to do. Help people who need it the most; put money into their hands, through strengthening social safety nets; increase their child benefit allowances. And wait until the United States decides on its course of action before becoming embroiled in supporting failing American-based industry here in Canada.
When you make your decision on our current state of affairs I hope public opinion will have some baring. It is my view if the coalition goes ahead it will not improve the economy but IT WILL also split the country more so than ever - clearly that is a far more deadly event than our economic situation. As such I see only two choices, call an election or Mr. Harper continues to govern (status quo). Unless you can lock the three little boys (Mr. Layton, Mr. Harper, Mr. Dion) in a room till they settle their differences and come out as one.
NOTE: I agree with all the above points too.
Yours truly
I find it alarming and distasteful that the NDP and Liberals would seek the co-operation of a party which is dedicated to destroying Canada as we know it, in an effort to thwart the wishes of the Canadian Electorate. Considering the unstable economic conditions here and the world over, this is not the time to plunge the country into further instability.
As I am sure you are aware, national economic markers like the value of the dollar and the price of stocks have deteriorated even further since this irresponsible action by the losers in the last election.
If the Canadian people wanted Stephan Dion as Prime Minister, they would have voted for a majority of Liberal candidates. Obviously, they did not.
Had the Bloc Quebecois run candidates in all of the provinces, they would have had some qualification to represent the whole of Canada. As it is they only represent that part of Quebec which would like to separate from Canada.
With all due respect, I humbly request that as Her Majesty's representative in Canada, you deny these power hungry, treasonous politicians the right to ride roughshod over the wishes of the Canadian electorate.
Frances and Jules Sobrian, MD
Omemee, Ontario
K0L 2W0
It has been a very democratic week in Canadian politics and also a sad one. First, I would recommend that you make a decision in the best interest of the country and deny and reject any potential request from Mr.Harper's to suspend or dissolve the parliament. The opposition has every right under the constituion to make a government especially in a minority government. How dare the Prime Minister of Canada use the economic troubles to pursue his evil ideas of damaging the democratic and political instiutions so that only his party can exist and rule the country. Instead of trying to correct the economic problems and make a concerted efforts with the opposition to find ways to bring economic relief to struggling sectors, he goes on to deny the public servants the right to strike and cut off political fundings. Basically his intent was to make this a dictatorship country where nobody has the guts to stand to him and his party.
I would appreciate if you could ask the Prime Minister to gain confidence of the House to see if he is really the Prime Minister of this country. He will fail either this month or next month and the only viable option for you is to give the opposition a chance to form the government. There is no way Canadians will like to go to another election especially during these economic times.
Secondly, the sad part is it is amazing to see how Canadian lack the knowledge of their parliamentry system. We think of ourself as the champion of democracy and we have no idea of what it is. To say the a coalition government is "unconstitutonal" just proves this argument.
Thanks and hope you take my recommendations.
The people of this country already picked who they thought should be Prime Minister of Canada. It seems to me, and many others that I have talked to, that this is either a bloodless coup, or a grab for power at the expense of Democracy.
Sincerly,
Terry Catney
I regret that you had to return to Canada early to tend to the political madness that has taken over Parliament. We hear of undemocractic activity in other countries (Thailand at the moment), but who imagined that here in the True North Strong & Free, we would see a coup d'etat by an unholy triumvirate, plotting to replace a duly-elected P.M. Please, please bring an end to this ludicrous partisan warfare that threatens to make us a laughingstock in civil society. Please do not accept the coalition's proposal. We will gladly go to the polls in the dead of winter if need be to choose a P.M. to lead our beautiful country. It's time for all Canadians to come to the rescue and participate in democracy by turning out to vote.
Michaëlle Governor General of Canada
I feel disgusted that the Liberal Party and the NDP are trying to grab power even though Canadians about 7 weeks ago, in mid-October, showed they are more for a Conservative government than for a Liberal or NDP one.
It is my hope that the voter-population can see the hoax in the Liberal economic plan, which will waste billions of tax-payers money while encouraging those who are hooked for just getting government funds. Such a plan will deepen the economic depression rather than lifting us up from it. There is no use in helping some car makers who are not going to survive in the next 5 years if they do not re-structure and re-negotiate with their trade unions for a market-workable plan.
The worst part of the coalition is not only the hypocrisy in covering up the cause for the coup for power, which is the cutting of government funding for political parties. What makes it shameful to Canadians is the fact that the Liberal and NDP will not be legal to govern without the coalition of another party which aims at separation from Canada, Bloc Quebecois. Quebec is known to us for its excessive draining of resources via the federal government transfer payments.
Quebec's population is less than 1/4 of Canada's, yet it draws federal funding well over its fair share. Bloc Quebecois could certainly get a lot more under the table than what has been disclosed during their press interview.
To any sensible person, such a coalition will not be for the benefit of this country.
It will further fragmentize Canada rather than unifying this country.
Sincerely,
WL
I, along with my wife wish to express our concerns for the proposed coalition government. We live in a democratic country that has a long and proud history. This proposed coalition government is comprised of parties that did not win the Federal election. We all had the opportunity to vote for the government that we wanted, and now that will be taken away by politicians hungry for power. Our government is not perfect, because it is run by humans who are prone to fail, but it is the one that we as Canadians voted for in October. DO NOT LET THIS COALITION HAPPEN. I would rather have an election called again to vote, than to have my rights as a Canadian citizen trampled on by 3 opposition parties.
Cal Bergen
Surrey, BC
It is an indication of how outraged I am at the prospect of the opposition parties forming a government without voter participation that I write to you. I can only hope that you will find the wisdom to see that this is a gross insult to democracy in our country. I fail to see how this differs, with the exception of there being no violence, from a coup or for that matter, treason. We must have more respect for the people who vote a government in, from all polititions.
This was done in the type of underhanded manner that our troops have fought against in many parts of the world.
As an ex miltary person I find this move very disgusting.
Please do not them get away with it.Let the people speak.
A coalition government is not what Canadians have chosen. The current government was chosen democratically at the poles. Like it or not. If the current government falls with a non confidence vote then Canadians must return to the polls.
mbaxter
Ontario
If and when you have to decide whether to let a coalition form the government, I think you should remember that in the our system, modeled after the British, Parliament is supreme. Though PM Dion might not be the best choice, if he can command the confidence of the House, he ought to govern. We have precedents of our own that advise such a course of action.
In spite of earlier remarks, there is nothing "undemocratic" about having our MPs choose the PM. This is how our system is meant to function. And, indeed, I voted for someone to represent my riding--"PM Harper" wasn't an option on my ballot.
This is the first time I have ever felt so upset about the possibility of my democratic right being taken from me that I believe it is necessary to voice my concern to you. I did not vote for the Conservative government in the last election. The person and party I voted for was because of the candidate in my area, not because of the leader. Having the three parties arbitrarily decide they are going to take over the government sounds very unethical and more like a coup to me. If the party I voted for wants to lead our Nation then they need to prove they are worthy of that and need to be voted in. I will keep it very simple. Please do not allow this coalition to take over our government. Please help to preserve our democratic rights!
Respectfully Yours
Doug Staines
Please use your influence, do not allow this proposed coalition government to become a reality. We elected our Members of Parliament to run the country - a coalition would only confuse matters by preventing the day-to-day business of the country, which is already proceeding at a snail's pace. I do not wholeheartedly support Stephen Harper but what purpose would be served by the continued political maneouvering of the opposition parties? The Bloc Quebecois (which is essentially a Provincial party and should not even be allowed status as a National party) is committed to destroying the country out of sheer spite. We are not paying the salaries of politicians to play games but to conduct the business of running the country! I and many others are thoroughly disgusted with their continued shenanigans.
It is with great dismay that I have been following the latest political events in Canada, that in my mind amount to no less than a coup by the power-thirsty men who forgot why and by whom they were elected to the Parliament in the 1st place. We are becoming a laughing stock starting to resemble a 3rd world country where governments replace each other with the lightning speed. Canada is a stable and democratic country. We are very proud to exercise our right to vote and to elect our government.
Your Excellency,
In your position you are both a symbol and an authority, and our eyes and our hopes are fixed on you to defend and uphold the deep-rooted democratic traditions of this country, and to stop a shameless manipulation of the parliamentary law by the NDP and Liberals. It would definitely be a waste of the taxpayers money to run another Federal election after we just had one, however, this waste and shame will be on the opposition parties, should they press the non-confidence vote on the current minority government. They cannot usurp our right to vote, we will do it again, if we have to!
This coalition does nothing except make a mockery of our great country. Two world wars were fought to preserve the freedom we have. This coalition is nothing more than power hungry political leaders trying to serve themselves. In October's election, the Conservatives, not the three other parties, were given a minority mandate to govern. Therefore the people should decide again who it is that we want to govern. Even with the economic uncertainty, money would be better spent now than years later fixing the mistakes that this coalition could create.
I thank you for your time,
I am deeply disturbed by the political events currently underway in Ottawa. I believe that it is crucial for the well being of our country that our elected politicians focus on the current domestic and global economic crisis. I also find it revolting that a political party whose mandate it is to divide Canada could end up holding the balance of power in a coalition government and thereby hold each and every Canadian outside the borders of Quebec at ransom.
It is possible that the future of this great country will rest in your hands in the coming days. I beg of you, as you struggle with the mammoth decisions, to carefully consider that the majority of Candaian voters, who believe in a strong and united Canada, voted for the Conservative party. Please respect the democratic process of this land and allow our current duly elected government to continue its efforts toward a prosperous and united Canada.
Sincerely,
Mylles Wildeman
Lanigan, Sk.
Good Evening. I am deeply concerned about the current state of our government and it has me very worried. I, along with many Canadians have just recently re-elected our current Prime Minister, Steven Harper, to govern Canada. The recent signing of the coalition of the 3 opposition parties has infuriated me. One issue is that the money spent on this recent election and the votes cast by the Canadian people would mean nothing if this coalition was allowed to take over as government. I believe that Canadians made it quite clear that the Liberals with Stephane Dion was definitely NOT who they wanted to lead this country. It is also appalling that the NDP and Liberals are working with the Bloc Quebecois, who quite obviously does not represent the voice of Canadians, and whose main objective is to separate Quebec from Canada. It is disgusting how the men leading these opposition parties would rather topple the government than work with them. I support the work and efforts of Mr. Harper and I truly hope that he will remain in power, as that is who we elected to lead us. Please consider our opinions in your decisions.
Thank you.
Kindly, ask yourself one simple question "What is best for Canada"?
Is it a coalition government comprised of 3 parties- one of which has a mandate to separate from Canada; one of which just received it's poorest electoral result since Confederation; and the third of which has fewer elected representatives than the Bloc Quebecois? In the midst of a global recession, is it in our country's best interest to have a Prime Minister that does not enjoy the support of his own party? Do you believe that those now seeking to form this coalition have the best interests of Canadians at heart or are they motivated by self interest and driven to seize power, regardless of the cost to average Canadians? To have three minority parties, with a 30 month fixed term, leading this nation is unimaginable and ineffective.
SIx weeks ago we were asked to do our civic duty and to elect a government who would lead us. The people spoke. Let our elected officials lead. Do not allow our government to fall by way of a coalition effort. Your nation needs you now.
Sincerely,
Susan Veres
the Right Honourable Michaëlle Jean, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D.
Governor General of Canada
Your Excellency: Please consider calling an election. Obviously there is a huge challenge but the Canadian people should decide who should take the lead. The present Government obviously made a huge mistake considering the present economic pressures. Only the people can choose who should be in power and the democratic process should be reinstated and there is obviously non confidence in the present government. We appreciate your kind consideration. Thank you. Judith Hayes
As a concerned Canadian citizen, I am writing to ask that you stop this absurb coalition. We the people voted the Conservatives in and it is wrong for the opposing parties to be able to form a coalition to hijack parliament! I think it is a waste of 300 million to have another election when we are in a time when we need to conserve spending as Stephan Harper is trying to do. If having an election is the only way we can stop this coalition then so be it. The voice of Canadians should rule, not polititions that only want more money and power only!
Sincerly,
L Hadley
I am writing you to convey my gravest concern over the political situation in Canada. I fear that the current politicing does not have the best intrest of Canadians at heart. During these troubled economic times we need strong leadership from one governing party. I believe a coalition governing party will not provide the stability and continuity that this country requires to get the job done efficiently and timely. If needs be I would rather have another election called so the people of Canada can speak clearly putting this matter to rest, otherwise we will have a coalition government thrust upon us.
Regards,
Dianne Bradley
Registered Nurse
It makes me so sad to see grown men and women in elected positions of power, behave as children.
I refer specifically to what is taking place in our very own Canadian Parliament.
I speak boldly and passionately from the heart.
This is my Canada.
This is my democratic country.
My parents immigrated from Holland just after the war, left their country and loved ones behind so that they could provide a better life for their children and family generations to follow.
It was a very difficult adjustment - but they worked hard to make this country of Canada a country of be proud of.
How we have let them down!
They believed in freedom of press, the freedom of religion, the freedom to vote for their leaders, the freedom to become "whatever and whoever" you wanted to be...to excel!!
Your Excellency...I weep...my tears fall uncontrollably on my ink...how can we have sunk so far?
Your Excellency...in the very recent October Federal Election, we the Canadian voters went to the polls and provided the Conservative Party with a very clear and strengthened mandate to lead this great country, my Canada - trustingly through a now global economic crisis.
Your Excellency...the opposition parties were so angry when the Canadians voted as they did...The Liberals were decimated and could not even stand behind their own leader Mr. Dion. When the polls were closed, his own ranks left him alone to face the media - a broken man.
Mr. Layton informed the public that the fight was not over. Since the election results, he has been lying in wait, planning, plotting to overthrow the elected Conservative, enlargened minority government.
The Bloc have admitted that they are self-serving and would prefer to be an independent province, separated from Canada.
The grass-roots platforms of all of these parties are as distant from one another as the North Pole is from the South Pole.
Your Excellency - they have openly expressed disdain for one another's policies. How is it that these "rebels" can lie and spin tales, telling the public that they have the best interests of all Canadians in mind. No, your Excellency, they are self-serving, power-hungry, angry individuals, looking to impose an unstable, un-elected Liberal-NDP-Separatist coalition on a nation who only in October made it clear to the world that their faith is in the ruling Conservative Party, a party which has, to this point in time, delivered stability in a time when it is so badly needed.
Your Excellency:
I plead with you that you will see this coup for what it is - put a stop to this madness - and plead for calmer heads to prevail. I plead that you will weigh all information fairly and I ask that you will oppose any political arrangement that replaces Her Majesty's democratically elected government without first consulting us, the Canadian public,in an open and democratic election.
I have opened and poured out my heart to you and I pray that God will lead you to the "right" decision.
Warmly and Sincerly,
Thelma Tessemaker
Abbotsford, BC
I, along with MOST of the others in this forum, would like to express my concerns about the recent creation of a coalition between the opposition members of this great nation... although I really wouldn't call the Bloc opposition... as I would say that if you want to be a NATIONAL party in the federal government and represent the country nationally... then you should have members in ALL provinces and territories... but in any case, this radical movement has the entire country in an uproar... with only very view agreeing with it! Looking through this blog I see that the majority of the viewers feel that the NDP/Liberal/Bloc are wrong in thinking that they can come to power in a democratic society by signing an agreement and having you endorse it! Even though we have just had a federal election... that was a democratic process.. and if need be I would much rather go back to the polls and vote in order to decide who should be running the country... not by NON-DEMOCRATIC processes... what is this showing the young people of our country and of countries around the world?? Why bother having a democratic process if you don't allow it to work... or give it time to work! The imature actions of the NDP/Liberal and of course the Bloc are a disgrace to this country... and they should all be ashamed of their actions... Interesting to note how quick they took action when Prime Minister Harper put forward the cost cutting measure of cutting back on the FREE money they receive from voter turnout... I for one agree that NONE of the polical parties should be benefiting from my vote! Put the money back into the people's pockets where it belongs!
Thank you for reviewing my opinion...
Sincerely
Diane Ehrentraut
Though I am still at the age where I am unable to vote, I still follow the political debates and troubles. As a young person who will be able to vote by the next election, I implore you to keep this Coalition government from forming. Frankly it terrifies me that the will of the voters can be rendered so useless. Shouldn't we have a right to choose who we have as our Prime Minister?
I know that many people of Canada have voted for the individual party leaders, but not all of them together! It's not right to just abruptly decide to do something like this. It's like they are creating a whole new party and expect it to govern a country that never heard of or supported the party beforehand. Please, Please, Please!!! On behalf of young voters to-be, I beg you to stop this Coalition from forming, and from neutralizing and ignoring the will of the voters, the CITIZENS!
It makes no sense and scares us all.
Thank you for your consideration,
GHSS student,
Kristin Antes
I respectfully submit that you should allow the coalition parties to form a government. Stephen Harper in the last election only received 35% of the popular vote. Only 60% of those who could vote voted. In fact he only had the support of 21% of all Canadians who voted. When a Canadian votes, one votes for a person who is a member of a political party. The manner in which the constitution is written does not mention that a party is elected - members of parliament are elected and those who share like political aims get together and form the government. That is what the Conservative Party did. The members of the party only continue to govern while they have the confidence of the rest of those elected member of parliament. It has been shown that the majority of the members of this parliament do not have confidence of the Conservative member to govern. Canadians did not elect members of any one party to a majority and under Canadian constitutional law if a group of members with like goals can get together and form a majority it has a legal right to form a government. With this in mind you should allow the coalition to form a government. When Stephen Harper called the last election he stated that parliament was unworkable and you allowed an election to be called even though no vote of confidence had been taken and the date of the election contravened the fixed election date act. At that time you could have asked those in opposition to form a government. Proroguing the house will only delay the process that is legitimate and will lead to the downfall of the Conservatives.
Please take this into consideration when making your decision.
Terry Middlemiss
No government is perfect and the current government is no exception however they were duly elected by the people of Canada. We did not elect the NDP or the Liberals or the Bloc. In my opinion the current situation is an embarrasment to democracy. I sincerly hope that Prime Minister Harper and his Conservative government remains firmly in place to do what they were elected to do. In these uncertain economic times we need a focused leader and a strong government. This possible coalition government is nothing but self serving and short sighted. I hope that common sense prevails and that democracy can proudly raise it's head in our great country.
Sincerely,
Mike Lacelle
I, along with others in this forum, would like to express my concerns about the recent creation of a coalition between the opposition members. Who knew that the NDP and Liberals were going to be joining forces with the Bloc, a party dedicated to the separation of Quebec. This change in policy no longer allows the NDP or Liberals to represent the majority of voters, and I feel that this now makes the coalition undemocratic and unrepresentative of the majority of Canadians.
Also, the coalition would put into power a PM who Canadians wholeheartedly rejected in the last election and a man who's own party is ready to replace him. I feel it prudent to point out that in any other nation in the world, a leader who was not elected by the people is never recognized as it's true leader by other world bodies and disposed of eventually. It seems now, the coalition will stop at nothing to provide instability at a time when stability is what is needed most. Please ensure that democracy rules and prevent the coalition from obtaining power. If you have lost faith in the government to govern at this time, allow the electorate to make the decision on what to do now by a vote.
Sincerely,
Todd Sykes
I don't consider myself particularly active in politics. I have never written to an elected official, nor am I connected to any party. However, like many of the people who have commented above, I am also concerned about the Canadian political situation.
The current minority government may have made some plans and statements that the opposition parties are not in support of, but this is not enough of a reason to bring down the government and replace it with a coalition. This approach would serve to negate the decision of voters. In addition, with the current turmoil in the global economy, more uncertainty in the Canadian political system would surely be more damaging than beneficial.
Please do what you can to prevent this coalition of parties from taking over power in our country.
I must state my demand as a Citizen to choose my own government. If some citizens and I should stress CITIZENS in our government have threatened to strike down the current government and that they want to gain that power for themselves then we as Canadians must exercise our responsibilities, rights and obligations to Canada, our fellow citizens and ourselves to choose for ourselves. I believe in democracy not in an oligarchy.
Thank you for the right to express my opinion to you and my fellow citizens.
I would like to voice my strong opinion that the coalition should not be given the opportunity to govern our country. As a citizen who has voted in every single election, I look on with disgust at what these men are trying to do with the decision that was made by the Canadian people at the election held only six weeks ago. If this coalition succeeds, democracy in Canada will surely be harmed. If holding another election were a third option, then I would be glad to go to the polls again.
Sincerely,
Monika Rondeel
the Right Honourable Michaëlle Jean, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D.
Governor General of Canada
Thank you for the hard work you do representing our country.
Currently, as a citizen of Canada, I am embarassed as to how we must be perceived by the rest of the world. This truly is a nightmare. Our leaders should be working together to pull us through this period of uncertainty.
No matter which party is elected by the people of our country to govern (whether they are Conservative, Liberal, NDP, Bloc), they deserve our support while they are in power. If we have a problem with their leadership, our voice (as citizens) will be heard in the next election.
Please support all Canadians. We voted for the party in power and trust their decision-making abilities. Please do not allow a newly formed (self-appointed, power-hungry) coalition government to undermine them.
Sincerely, Helen Vanderlinden
Let me begin by saying recently I have begun to really pay attention to the different government parties and who is going to do what for our country. I am very displeased on how Canadians are being treated by the Layton Dion and the Bloc. I believe the people already voted. Like it or not Mr. Harper was elected. Now we have the 3 parties who's leader's did not win acting like kids who did not get there own way. They are basically saying Canadians do not know what they want or how to vote so we will bully are way in to leading the goverment and the heck with what Canadians want we are going to do what we want. I think their efforts would be better used in coming up with ways to keep our country out of a recession and so we do not end up like the US. I feel Canadians have spoken so plese think long and hard about the Canadians who have spoken and leave Mr. Harper as leader of our country that is what Canadians wanted. Please your excellency put an end to this madness and let's get back to more press issues with our contry.....
the Right Honourable Michaëlle Jean, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D.
Governor General of Canada
I hope you had a wonderful trip to the Czech Republic, Slovakia, and Hungary. I hope Canada can have closer ties with all 3 nations in the future.
I am amazed at the gall of previous commenters in their efforts to subvert the democratic process. I think a coalition would be the most logical outcome of the situation we are in now, as dealing with an autocratic Stephen Harper seems to be more impossible for the present government's functioning than any deal struck with the Bloc Québecois. But I do not believe in pressuring you to decide on any one option, I'll leave that to classless Conservatives. I trust in your judgment, comprehensive perspective and wisdom to make the right decision for our country , even if it is not a decision shared by myself. Please don't let yourself be pressured by anyone, Canadians will respect your leadership out of love for our country.
Sincerely,
Matthew McMillan
I never ever thought that I would see the day that Mr Dion and Layton would shake hands with the leader of the Block, a party designed to destroy the fabric of Canada.
Well, that day has come, and it is therefore a very black day indeed.
Please do everything in your power to maintain the unity of this country when making a decision on the current crisis.
Many heads need time to cool before we should proceed to the next step.
Sincerely,
Travis,
Vancouver Island, B.C.
I am very proud to be a Canadian. I have exercised my rights as a Canadian at every election since I became old enough to vote. During that time, while I may not have agreed with the outcome, I believed that Canadians had spoken and I accepted their wishes ( not that I had much choice).
This current effort by what can only be described as poor losers to hijack our government by back room negotiations is despicable. Some people on this blog have voted for the NDP, some for Liberals, some for Conservatives and, as near as I can tell, none for the Bloc. You have to ask yourself why? I believe that it is because everyone of the people that have replied are passionate Canadians. We love our country, which includes Quebec. For the Liberals and NDP to cobble together a government with a group which espouses the destruction of our beloved country, I can only say that they need to change their position or face an election. What kind of deals did they make with the leader of the Bloc, who said on the news last night that he does not care about Canada, only about Quebec.I am not eager to spend the money to have another election, especially given our current tough economic times, but I would rather have an election than have a group of carpetbaggers hijack the country.
Your Excellency, it is your turn to stand up for the Canadian people and our rights. It is obvious that the elected persons pimping themselves for power will not. Please do the right thing for us.
Sincerely,
Pat Gleeson
Burnaby, British Columbia
Please do everything within your power to prevent Stéphane Dion from becoming Prime Minister of Canada. Our Prime Minister should be voted in by Canadians, not hand picked from the 3+ parties that lost the election.
If the government should fall with a non confidence vote I request that a new election be called and the people be allowed to make their choice of who is to govern Canada.
D Andrade
Mississauga, ON
I am a very unhappy Canadian these days. I have used my democratic right to vote all my life but I am very discouraged to see that the Liberals and Ndp and Bloc can take over Government without being formally elected.
Please give us, the people, the opportunity to decide whether or not we would like this new government.
Thank you for your time, your loyal servant - Ryan Langford
You are the only person who can stop this coalition travesty. How dare they cancel my vote. All of these men lost in the recent election because the people of Canada did not want them. Now they believe they can ram this unholy coalition down the throats of those who rejected them. Should they gain power with their cheating, sneaky ways, they will destroy Canada. I can guarantee you they do not care for the Canadian people or they would not be trying to destroy our country during an economic crisis. How dare they take away my vote. By creating the coalition and all it stands for, they are telling me my vote is of no value. It doesn't matter that we voted for Prime Minister Harper, if they get their way, it will be as though we never voted. I vote faithfully and have always thought it was my duty to do so. I believe they should be stopped in their tracks . They are no friends of Canada and we don't want them here.
Please, stop this from happening. We are begging you.
Sincerely,
Cheryl Brodgesell
Edmonton, Alberta
I find the present situation in Parliament disturbing. It is not encouraging and completely undemocratic to see a government fairly elected by the people get ousted and replaced by an individual aspiring to be prime minister that Canadians did NOT vote for.
For the sake of Canada, and the democratic principles it stands for, I hope that you will do the right thing and end this nonsense to topple a government that was elected just two months ago.
Politics may be dirty and unfair, but do not let it sully our democratic principles.
-Ranj
We have just elected a party and a Prime Minister, that is, the Conservative Party and Stephen Harper to lead this country during the most difficult financial time in living memory.The Canadian People did not elect Stephane Dion, Jack Layton or for that matter Gilles Duceppe. What these three men are doing is undemocratic and totally runs contrary to the will of the Canadian voter. It is a cute and "dirty trick" that belittles the Canadian people, we deserve better. It would be best if you had the powers to put these three "stooges" into detention, maybe make them senators for life with no chance for parole.
Please let the Prime Minister and his Party continue to lead us through this difficult time, let Curly, Larry and Moe stay in opposition as mandated by the Canadian people.
When Canada voted it was clear that most Canadians supported the Conservative platform as laid out in the election(more so then any other party) and hence formed a minority government, now this coalition apparently has a new and different platform (apparently the platforms laid out by each coalition member party in the election wasn't what Canadians wanted as demonstrated by the democratic process) and if this madness can’t be stopped and the coalition is so sure that this is what Canadians want then let the Canadian public vote on it, see what Canadians think, if that matters anymore. Otherwise, I and I’m sure I’m not alone in saying this, will be unable and unwilling to support a government that no one voted for and that could be a disaster for the country which I love.
Sincerely,
Blake McNeill
As a westerner who feels that a Prime Minister from the west would help to reduce resentment from the west regarding what most westerners feel are unfair voting policies, I must present you with a perspective regarding this political grandstanding, and desperate stunt that the coalition parties are attempting to overthrow the government with. After looking at the voting results in the last election and seeing the fact that the Bloc Quebecois received 10 percent of the popular vote, but 17 percent of the seats, I was outraged (please forgive me if my information is not precise). I simply do not understand how a party whose sole purpose is to break up the country can, first, receive federal funding, second, get an over-representative amount of seats, and third, become part of a leadership coalition. Please do not allow this desperate act, by a group that was fairly and soundly (each of them) defeated, rob Canadians of the government that they elected. Three men that the country did not want as their leader should not be able to "backdoor" their way into power. Because that is all this is about - power - not "lies", or anything else. Frankly, it is about a group of sore losers franctically trying a last ditch ploy. Please hear what Canadians are saying and know this: I am this outraged, and I did not vote Conservative, nor am I an active supporter of the Conservative party. Please simply turn this coalition down - we cannot afford yet another vote - especially after the three coalition parties criticized the Conservatives for only costing Canadians money with the last vote; which simply reeks of hypocrisy. We have other concerns, such as the economic situation, and the environment, to consider in our politics, that are far more pressing than this.
Thank you for listening,
Michael McDonald
I was born and raised in Canada, In this country I have personally overcome...child poverty, child abuse, teen pregnancy, the financial & emotional roller coaster of life as a parent of a child with an intellectual disability not to mention life's more expected burdens such as debt, loss of a loved one and the loss of employment to name a few. It is after midnight 45 years of Life's ups and downs later and the actions of those I have funded without choice through my pay cheque is what motivates me to cry out for your help? Over the years there have been so so many questionable decisions made in our courts and overturned in our higher courts because UNELECTED persons are able to make decisions that are dictated to Canadians under the guise that it is what is best for us. There is only one way to know what is best for Canadians and that is through our ELECTED officials. It is inconceivable that my ONLY ability to have my voice counted in this Country is at risk of being overturned.
As a truly shaken Canadian I say... God Bless America because only in Canada could this or would this blatant act of treason be contemplated never mind face the risk of being tolerated.
I am writting to you to ask that you do not allow Mr Harper to close government until he feels he can beat the present situation. His party caused the situation and should be made to deal with it. I feel that in these times of financial uncertainty that we can not allow the government not to be available. We need to have some movement some stimulation in our economy. If Mr Harper shuts down the government there will be nothing. He is still acting like a bully who wants to take his ball and go home. These government employees and that is what they are employees need to earn their money. Are they going to give up their salaries when they shut down parlament OH NO they will not. What other job can you have when things dont work you way you close the job. For Canadas sake Madam I ask you please think very carefully before you make this decision.
Thank you very kindly
Sandra Marsden
Michaëlle Governor General of Canada
I would like to start by thanking you for your excellent service to all Canadians. I feel we have entered a very sad point in Canadian history. I will admit my allegiance to the Liberal party for the last twenty five years.
Now I am absolutely ashamed for my loyalty to the Liberal party. What they have tried to achieve is outright desperation. I voted solely for the Liberal party, not a coalition. No part of my election ballot asked for my support of a coalition. I accepted the Liberal defeat, and will always respect the voice of the people. Now I understand the actions of Mr. Dion and Mr. Layton were not a last minute decision. They are very sneaky and have been working on this plan for some time. I feel Mr. Harper has shouldered the blame for our faltering economy, we tend to forget what role the US has played to destroy the global economy.
I ask that you please grant the people of Canada the opportunity to choose who they feel fit to be our Prime Minister.
That would also give me the opportunity to correct the many mistakes of the past and vote for a party that respects the peoples choice.
Good luck Mr. Harper.
Thank you kindly
I am sorry to hijack this thread, however with the amount of one sided opinions I feel I had to write.
I fully support the coalition government. The Conservative party was given a mandate to govern with the help of another party, which is something they simply failed to achieve. Instead they decided to ignite a powder keg by offering a stimilus package that isn't, inequality for women workers, restrictions on strike rights and a direct attack on the financing of the political parties which insure a fair democracy.
This was either a very poorly made plan, or a plan that Harper hatched to polarize the debates and try to get more support in provinces other then Quebec.
While I usually attribute to incompetence instead of attributing to malice, in this case I do beleive that Harper and Flaherty acted malicously to divide Canada and try to gain support in the rest of Canada to eventually get a majority government. This kind of charade cannot be allowed to continue and needs to be put to an immediate stop. Proroging the session will only give Harper more time to launch attack ads against the coalition.
Already we can see his two facedness by having different ads in Quebec then in the rest of the country.
I have been a Canadian all of my life, I have voted all of my life. The will of the people of Canada has been expressed on October 14th. The majority (62%) of the vote when to MPs which are outside of the Conservative party.
It is clearly an understatement to say that Canadian’s politics is going through an uncommon (although interesting) time. While being more federalist than separatist, and far from sure as to the need for the Bloc Québécois at Ottawa, I am quite surprised by the recent uproar created by the potential coalition.
What Canada needs more than anything at this time is to have the House of Common put all its efforts to address the current economic uncertainty and crisis, and not to have our representatives continue bickering as they so often do.
I would remind my fellow citizens who have written to you recently that, in election time, we do not elect a Prime Minister, but representatives. If the majority of these representatives consider a political move that doesn’t contravene the rules of the parliament (which I understand to be the case if you were to recognized the proposed coalition), it may be preferable to allow it than to have a House of Common that will everything by effective, and therefore unable to support the Canadians in the difficult times to come.
However strange the coalition (and believe me, I was initially quite by the three opposition parties considering it), it will only be effective if they work together, focusing on their points of agreements rather than on their divergences. This may well represent the best way (at least, under the current context) to have a majority of representatives at the House of Common going in the same direction and agreeing on the actions to be taken in those difficult times.
It is obvious you will have to take a very important decision in the next days. I am confident you will be able to disregard the ongoing “political games” of all parties, listen to all stakeholders and make a decision that will allow the House of Common to work as efficiently as possible. We all know Canada requires it to remain strong and unified.
Bonne chance, Votre Excellence, dans cette décision. Et merci de nous offrir l’opportunité de partager nos opinions sur ce blog.
It is with saddness and anger that I write to you today. I have never felt so disapointed to be a Canadian in all my life. I tried to explain to my 15 year old daughter why the votes of Oct. 4 would not count anymore, and frankly I couldn't make it make sense. I don't feel like I live in a democracy when 3 fat cat sore loosers can change what the Canadian people have chosen. There was a clear message sent that neither Stephan Dion or Jack Layton were wanted as Prime Minister. They have chosen to disregard the Canadian voters and find thier own way to get into power. They have sold out all thier integrity to be willing to partner with a political power that wants nothing but to tear the country apart. This small party, representing 1 province in Canada, and having separatist views will have all the power, because the Liberal and NDP cannot pass a motion without them. This is definatly not what the majority of Canadians voted for. Governer General I beg you to stop this non democratic, sneaky behavior. I know that your options are limited, but I hope that even if the only way you can stop it is to call another election, that you will do it so that the Canadian people can speak. This kind of behavior should not be rewarded. Thank you for your careful consideration of this matter.
Kary Holloway
Abbotsford, B.C.
Les Canadiens sont allés aux urnes dernièrement et ont fait un choix.
Ils ont élu un gouvernement presque majoritaire. M. Harper a gagné démocratiquement cette élection.
Voilà que des politiciens frustrés veulent faire un coup d'état , ils veulent renverser ce gouvernement que nous avons choisi car ils estiment être de meilleurs gestionaires. Cependant ces gens n'ont aucune légitimité , pourquoi changerions nous les règles de la démocratie.C'est un jeu dangereux,qui aura de lourdes conséquences sur l'unité canadienne et notre foi en la démocratie.
Madame dite non à cette coalition
The recent minority Conservative government was given a mandate by the people of Canada to work with other political parties for the betterment of the people of Canada. Unfortunately--as can be witnessed by deed and words--they have refused this mandate.
The leadership of the remaining political parties have come to an agreement to govern this country through a coalition government, in which the voices of the vast majority of the Canadians are reflected. This is precisely the mandate that the Canadian voters wanted. With all due respect, I would remind Your Excellency that ALL Members of Parliament are equally imbued with the same privilege to represent and govern the constituents that elected them.
Currently, it is rumoured that the Prime Minister is going to ask you to end the current Parliament. To allow him to do so would be an affront to democracy, not to mention particularly damaging given the current economic crisis. The people have spoken: they want a coalition government.
Please do not become the Katherine Harris of Canada. Canadian Citizens' elect a government and we do everything we can to ensure that Canadian Citizens' votes are counted. The votes were counted, we have a minority government, if others want to lead the government and become prime minister and cabinet, then let them be elected to govern by the Canadian Electorate. It was made clear that the Canadian Electorate did not want Mr. Dion or Mr. Layton as a Prime Minister.
As the previous citizens of our nation have already expressed, I am deeply concerned over our currrent goverment. As this is apparently the only avenue that i, Joe Public, can take, and be heard, i will attempt to express how i feel on the matter.
I am profoundly Canadian, and deeply patriotic. I ALWAYS excercise my Right To Vote, and wear the flag proudly on my jacket every day. This past election i voted NDP. The reason I say this is to assure you that I am not coming for a pro-Conservative bias.
This buisness of a "Coalition" goverment MUST not be allowed to happen in the way it is being sought out. The Conservative goverment was lawfully elected, may i repeat, ELECTED. If the coalition of the Liberals, the NDP, and the bloc actually are permitted to gain office, it would be an affront to voters everywhere.
As a comprimise, force a election. If the coalition really does represent the interests of The People, then let US DECIDE!
I believe this is your time. We as a country are being watched right now very closely. If this coalition is allowed to take place, all our previous efforts as peace keepers in countries with dictatorships and military takeovers of governments are put in a shameful light. We must hold up democracy at all costs. I know this is going to be hard for you but let the people decide or just say no to this coalition. It will be very nice to have you back in Canada.
I love Canada. I grew up in Alberta and now live in Ontario. I have travelled this country from coast-to-coast. I have worked in a cultural industry my whole life. In fact, I have edited many books on Canadian history.
As a proud Canadian who understands the complexities of our nation, I humbly request that you not hand over power to the coalition. Canadians are feeling demoralized, and disenfranchising us makes matters worse. In the last election, we did not choose Mr. Dion to be our prime minister. We did not choose a coalition to govern us. Please do not let the coalition tell us that we are not intelligent enough to decide who governs us.
Please take this decision to the people. We need to choose who will lead us through these tough economic times.
Sincerely,
L. Lymer
Toronto, ON
I do not want Stephane Dion as my Prime Minister. I am very dismayed at the political actions of the Conservatives last week. They made a big mistake. I hope that the Prime Minister and his party will apologize to the House of Commons and Canadians. I also hope that the government will be given some time to re-consider their actions and come forth with a budget that can regain the confidence of the house. My business puts me in communication with Canadians across the country. We never discuss politics. Well that sure changed this week. Nobody I have spoken to would support a government lead by Mr. Dion, we all feel that Canadians really made a clear choice in the last election. We put our confidence in Mr. Harper, granted in a minority, but much more confidence than any of the other political party leaders. Please respect this confidence and do not allow this coalition to govern.
Thanks You.
Eugene Gorgichuk
Ottawa Ontario
I am writing to you as a Canadian citizen who is originally from the US. I find it interesting that so many of the outraged comments seem to reflect confusion with our American electoral system, as though Stephen Harper were the elected president of a republic rather than prime minister of a parliamentary democracy. It seems to me that what's happening is normal. Since I work with many boards of directors, the situation seems analogous: people who have the right to vote elect the board members, then those board members choose their officers: president, treasurer, etc. If the board president is not able to exercise the leadership needed for the board to fulfill its responsibilities to the stakeholders and is not supported by most of the other board members, they have the right and duty to give the office to another member. It can be messy and unpleasant, but it's normal and healthy and it happens all the time. Likewise in other countries that share our parliamentary system of government. Now, in your role as Governor General, you are receiving a great deal of attention and pressure. I am therefore writing to tell you that I believe there are many Canadians like myself who understand parliamentary democracy, we're not quaking in our boots because it's functioning as it should, and we send you our support.
Yours sincerely,
Judith Shapiro
L'actuelle crise économique mondiale frappe davantage et depuis plus
longtemps les États-Unis que le Canada.
Néanmoins, jusqu'ici, le Gouvernement Bush n'a pas encore accordé,
par exemple, de programmes d'aide aux grandes Compagnies automobiles;
mais il attend que celles-ci lui présentent des plans et des demandes qui soient compatibles avec les graves et inusitées circonstances présentes.
Ces mêmes Compagnies automobiles américaines font aussi face à des
difficultés importantes dans leurs usines installées au Canada.
En tant que responsable des Finances du Gouvernement canadien, il est donc tout à fait logique et essentiel que le Gouvernement Harper fasse également montre d'une grande prudence, avant de risquer de dilapider,
dans cette industrie comme dans d'autres domaines, des sommes énormes provenant des contribuables canadiens.
La seule véritable raison pour laquelle trois Partis de l'opposition
viennent de former une «coalition» à Ottawa, c'est pour tenter d'usurper au Gouvernement canadien démocratiquement réélu tout récemment, le pouvoir qu'eux n'ont pu obtenir lors de ces dernières
élections fédérales. Cette «coalition» clame vouloir le bien du peuple alors qu'en fait, elle planifie voler le pouvoir fédéral en faisant
passer son «putsch» pour un geste démocratique, désintéressé et humaniste.
La façon avec laquelle sera réglée cette crise canadienne exceptionnelle nous démontrera si le Canada est vraiment une Démocratie parlementaire, ou s'il est plutôt une «fausse Démocratie» dans laquelle un Gouvernement légitimement élu peut être renversé,
sous un prétexte fallacieux, par la première coalition venue.
Nous vous remercions, Excellence, de l'attention que vous porterez à ce courriel.
Pierre et Ghislaine Dumouchel,
Outaouais, Québec
I feel that I must write to you concerning our current political situation.
I am frustrated and angry about the way all of the political parties are playing politics during a time of unprecedented economic turmoil. My sons' education funds have recently lost 25% of their value. I know of friends and acquaintances that have lost their jobs or have been laid off for several months.
I think that we should be looking at these times as an opportunity to stengthen our country by investing in infrastructure and education. Not only will this put Canadians to work, but put us in good position to earn new business for the future. Products that will be produced in 5-10 years from now are not being produced today. We need to put ourselves into a position to capitlize on that.
"If you build it, they will come". I think this is self explanatory.
Once a non-confidence motion has been passed, I believe that you have 2 options. One, to disolve government and have another general election. We have just spent $400 million on the last election. I think this would be an unpopular choice. Second, to ask the opposition parties to form a coalition government. Again, I think this would an unpopular choice.
I think that all parties should be asked to set political differences aside and do the things necessary to put country back on the path to prosperity. Please get the boys out of the sandbox and tell to grow up.
Thank you for your consideration,
Jim Ratcliffe
Georgetown, ON
I also urge you to prevent Stephen Dion from becoming Prime Minister. We ELECTED the current government and we need to see it through. PM Harper deserves the chance to govern as we have elected him to do and I believe this entire situation is ridiculous. At the very, very least I want the chance to vote and would gladly welcome another election rather than having the elected government ousted in this fashion. Lastly, under so circumstances do I want a Separatist having ANY say in how my country is governed!!!!!
Sincerely
Tamara Dundas
Clear Lake
Manitoba
I'm writing to ask you, if you have the means to do so, to refuse the request to prorogue from Mr Harper. He does not have the confidence of the house, and has shown he will not willingly work with the opposition in a minority situation. Our economy needs much overdue attention, and another delay will only make things worse. From all the media reports I've read, Canadians are split almost 50/50 on this issue, so another election would most likely result in another minority. For this reason, I feel the coalition deserves a chance as soon as possible. They were elected by the people like all MP's and despite their difference, they have shown they can agree. During these difficult times, no government at all is not the answer in my opinion.
Thank you and best wishes,
J Graham.
Je suis tout à fait d'accord avec la coalition pour défaire le gouvernement actuel. Il fait rappeller que cette coalition représente la majorité de la chambre, élue démocratiquement et donc tout à fait légitime. Le premier ministre actuel fait preuve de basse partisanerie dans un contexte d'incertitude ceci est inacceptable. Les partis de la coalition ont choisis de mettre de coté leurs différents afin de s'unir, faire front commun et d'offrir aux canadiens un gouvernement responsable qui va au-delà de la partisanerie afin de s'occuper de choses importantes comme l'économie. Dans le contexte actuel le gouvernement actuel est un danger pour l'économie et l'avenir du pays. Il choisit de semer la zizanie au lieu d'admettre ses torts et cherche à faire porter les blames sur ses adversaires alors que c'est lui qui est le premier responsable de tous ses problèmes
À première vue, je me suis réjoui de la coalition des partis de l'opposition pour prendre le pouvoir de faire face aux graves difficultés économiques qui rattraperont les Canadiens comme tout le reste du monde. Je continue de blâmer M. le Premier Ministre Harper d'avoir si malhabilement attaquer le problème en faisant de la petite «politique» et négligeant carrément de proposer des pistes de solution pour faire face aux problèmes financiers du Canada comme du reste du monde. Je le blâme de n'avoir consulté aucun autre parti pour s'assurer qu'une majorité de députés approuve ses plans.
En y réfléchissant bien, je me questionne maintenant sur la légitimité et la moralité du projet. Certes, mathématiquement, la coalition représente une majorité de Canadiens mais ce n'est pas dans ce nouveau rôle qu'ils s'apprêtent à jouer qu'on les a élus.
On ne peut douter de l'honnêteté des trois chefs qui signent cette alliance mais je pense que si M. Dion peut plaider la naïveté et l'inexpérience, on ne pourra en dire autant de messieurs Layton et Duceppe, deux pros de la politique qui n'en sont pas à une astuce près.
Le fait que le Bloc Québécois joue un rôle important en détenant la balance du pouvoir d'un gouvernement dont à priori ils refusent de faire partie à cause de leurs idéaux séparatistes, me semble à tout le moins... bizarre.
Le fait que le Québec, il y a quelques semaines, n'a donné de majorité de voix ni aux Libéraux, ni aux Conservateurs, ni au Nouveau Parti Démocratique, mais bien au Bloc Québécois, n'est-il pas immoral d'offrir le pouvoir à M. Dion et nouveaux associés et la balance du pouvoir au Bloc?
Quelle que soit votre décision, madame, elle déplaira. En autorisant la coalition, les provinces «conservatrices» vous accuseront de favoriser la «gouvernance» du pays par les séparatistes québécois. En refusant cette coalition, les Québécois vous accuseront d'ignorer la mathématique et d'être insensible à leurs revendications. Bloc et PQ vont sauter sur cette occasion pour dire comme on les maltraite en ce pays et demander d'en sortir.
Bref, madame, vous réussirez ce que le Parti Québécois et le Bloc Québécois n'ont pas réussi à faire: réunir les conditions gagnantes pour séparer le Québec du ROC.
Bonne chance, madame!
the Right Honourable Michaëlle Jean, C.C., C.M.M., C.O.M., C.D.
Governor General of Canada
It is with great sadness that I am sending you this message! Canada is very ill and the "doctors" charged with her care cannot agree on a method of treatment! Please come home, as soon as possible, to offer your guidance.
While we all have our own opinions on each of the leaders and members of parliament, as I watch the latest crisis evolve in Parliament, I am struck (and embarrassed) by the complete lack of respect shown by each of the leaders and members. This is appalling! Is it time to bring in a behavioural therapist to bring all parties back to the table and to teach each of the principals that as long as they put their own agendas ahead of the good of Canada, they will fail. At this time, my perception is that the Canadian government is completely dysfunctional and it is time that each member grew up and behaved in a manner appropriate to the position entrusted to him or her by the people of Canada!
Thank you and welcome home!!
Your Loyal Servant,
Madelaine Kilsby
Kitchener, Ontario
La présente crise à Ottawa démontre un sérieux problème dans la politique canadienne. Il est tout à fait illogique qu'un gouvernement puisse être élu, alors qu'il ne détient pas la majorité des voix au pays. Il faut absolument songer à faire une réforme urgente du système électorale. Les gouvernements minoritaires empêchent de faire avancer la situation canadienne. De plus, en tant de crise économique, nous devons avoir un Parlement fort qui détient un appui substantiel de la population, ce que le gouvernement Harper n'a pas.
Une élection imminente serait trop prématurée, d'autant plus qu'il faut agir maintenant pour l'économie et la société. Une coalition libérale-néodémocrate est la façon la moins coûteuse et la plus rapide pour remplir les objectifs démocratiques actuels. En effet, si deux partis forment le gouvernement, tous les électeurs qui ont voté pour soit l'un, soit l'autre sont représentés au sein du gouvernement. De plus, un troisième parti appuie cette coalition, ce qui signifie que les citoyens ayant voté pour ce parti seront également écouté. Dans le cas du gouvernement Harper, il n'y a que les électeurs de ce parti qui sont représentés.
Officiellement, l'ensemble des trois partis de l'opposition détient plus de la majorité des voix. Tout ceux qui affirment qu'une coalition est anti-démocratique, je leur réponds : « Où est la démocratie lorsqu'une minorité obtient le pouvoir ? », car c'est le cas en temps de gouvernement minoritaire.
Il faut à tout prix changer la Politique canadienne. Premièrement, le Chef d'un Parti ne devrait pas être député. Deuxièmement, les députés ne devraient pas être affiliés à un Parti. Troisièmement, l'élection du pouvoir exécutif devrait être un processus différent de l'élection du pouvoir législatif.
Pour terminer, j'aimerais vous remercier de votre écoute. Je tiens à vous rappeler que vous détenez le pouvoir de régler la situation.
Veuillez agréer, Votre Excellence, mes salutations les plus distinguées.
Jean-Philippe Lebrun
Étudiant en Droit
I am writing to express my concern over the possibility of a coalition government taking power from an elected one. I feel that the values and founding principles of the parties involved in the coalition have been compromised and are not representative of the support they received in the last election. Should the confidence vote be defeated in parliament, I ask that you strongly consider another election as the best solution to serve the will of the Canadian people.
I write as a proud but concerned Canadian. I am disappointed with parliament. I believe that Canadians voted for a minority government with the expectation that there would be at least a minimal level of civility and that the political parties would act within the bounds of their campaign promises.
I respectfully request that you remind MP's of their responsibilities to the people in these matters and take the steps within your power to influence them towards civil and honorable actions.
My personal belief is that it is not appropriate for a recently elected government to be replaced by a minority coalition prior to submission of a budget. If the Prime Minister requests that parliament be prorogued; I hope that it will be your pleasure to grant this request. My hope is that the passage of some time will allow parliament and Canadians a fulsome discussion of the economic issues and details of appropriate action. Granting an opposition coalition the right to govern on the basis of what I think most Canadians view as a political maneuver is quite probably not in the best interests of the country. The legitimacy of a coalition is increased only after a government defeat on a material matter such as a budget.
No matter what your decision on these matters; I respectfully request that you explain to the Canadian public the constitutional and parliamentary rules and traditions that apply. I believe that the electorate is not as well informed on these issues as they should be.
Respectfully
Jeff Wittstock
Calgary, Alberta
I am writing you as a concerned Canadian citizen and on behalf of dozens of my immediate friends and relatives. We strongly urge you reject this proposed coalition as a political group entitled to govern Canada at this time. Should Prime Minister be forced to come to you because of a nonconfidence vote, we urge you to reject any call for either an election or for a handing over of controls to the proposed coalition of opposition parties. We average Canadians have the right to expect functional and stable government. The proposed coalition cannot provide us with that. Taken together the three parties only barely have more seats than the conservative party. Additionally one significant member of that proposed coalition has the avowed mandate of the actual dissolution of Canada! Handing over the reins of government to such a group would be tantamount to an act of treason in the minds of me and my friends! We understand that your office has only limited options should this question be put to you. However, if you are required to, we strongly urge you to either refuse to accept the resignation of the current government or call for another election.
Respectfully yours,
Dr. Dave Kirby
Victoria BC
First I would like to thank you for all the hard work you are doing for Canadians. It's unfortunate your trip was cut short, however Canadians are in a history making situation at the moment and your judgment is of great importance. Many Canadians do not agree with this coalition. Some are saying it's like a coup. To seize power this way is not Canadian. The Canadian people beg you to allow for another election if things cannot be rectified. This is the Canadian way. Canadians truly believe if the coalition takes power, we will be in an economic disaster before we can say Oh My God!
I am outraged at the thought that 3 political leaders would go against the Government; elected by the majority of Canadians in the recent election with an increase of members.
I am further outraged that one of those leaders is determined to seperate Quebec from our nation - and will be in a position to assist in governing Canada with the intent to break away from Canada.
Please use your influence to restore stability in the country and grant this new government time to operate and further create the economic stability so desperately needed.
I am extremely concerned about the suitability of the current Conservative minority government to manage our economy in difficult times. We are facing an economic maelstrom unseen since the Great Depression. During the Great Depression we also had a Conservative government that refused to stimulate the economy, preferring instead to punish workers, women, and minorities. As a result the vast majority of the citizens of Canada suffered extremely. This government has not learned from that history and is repeating the same mistakes.
Please do not allow Stephen Harper to suspend parliament to keep himself in power as we cannot afford to wait for the government to act. The proposed coalition has put forth a package that promises to assist working people in the coming difficult times.
I encourage you to allow Parliament to work as it should. This is one of the first times in Canadian history that House is working as it should; members holding the government accountable for its behaviour. This is democracy at its best. Another election at this time is not required; we have elected our representatives and expect them to form a functioning government. Again, this is how our Parliament is supposed to work, but rarely does.
Je suis un québécois dans l'âme et j'ai compris que nous ne voulons pas a présent, se séparer du Canada. Je ne vote plus pour le Bloc, après trente ans d'essai, de support a la cause de l'indépendance, il est plus que temps que l'on passe a autre chose. Et maintenant, voici que les partis de l'opposition s'associe pour gouverner!!!. A mon humble avis, c'est tout a fait ridicule. Je suis profondément déçu de nos politiciens, autant du parti conservateur qui a manqué de réserve et de jugement que des autres partis qui semble prêt a tout pour faire un "trip" de pouvoir. Mme la Gouverneure, je vous demande de ne pas accepter la coalition des partis de l'opposition... que de nouvelles élections soient déclenchées, c'est a la population de décider qui doit gouverner.
respectueusement,
René Aussant
Sorel-Tracy
Québec
Thank you for the opportunity to communicate with you in this way. As a Canadian citizen, I am very concerned about the present situation that faces our country. The electorate has just given their voice so recently, yet that could be undermined by a coalition of unlikely partners. The financial stability of Canada could quickly be destabilized. Please be encouraged to do what is best for Canada. Renew our confidence in our government and assure us that our votes really do matter. If a non-confidence motion is passed, please return the vote to all of Canada for an election.
As a proud Canadian citizen, I must protest the current situation with our Federal politicans.
Canadians elected a conservative government and in this time of crisis should be allowed to continue to make decisions on our behalf. At the beginning of this Global crisis which was in no way started by a Canadian Government. It was satisfying to hear a well respected world organisation like O.E.C.D. claim that Canada had the most stable banking system in the world and that we were in a better postion than ANY of the G7 nations to survive this economic crisis.
I sincerely hope that you will not allow a coalition to replace the current government without calling an election and going back to the people of Canada.
I do NOT believe that this coalition is being formed in the best interest of our country. This is politcians taking advantage of a crisis situation for personal gain and for that I must condem them. This is a time for leadership and ALL members of parliament to work together until the global siuation stabalizes.
Sincerly
Bob Taylor
Niagara Falls
Ontario
As you return from your State visit I ask that you consider the plight of your fellow Canadians.I know how devoted you are to this country.
I support the Constitutional option of a Parliamentary Coalition and the ability of the Opposition to vote against a minority government.
I hope that you will not prorogue the house.This will only afford time for the current Priminister to flood the airways with his media attacks on the nobility of Mr.Dion
Your role is not an easy one and I respect that.I hope Canadians realize today that you play a vital role in our country.
You bring balance to what some would say is an irreconcilable difference.
Some may say you require the wisdom of Soloman
Dans ces temps extraordinaires, il faut prendre des mesures extraordinaires. La position du gouvernement Conservateur et son attitude face à ce qu'il croyait être une opposition morcelée nous a donné une crise sans précédent dans l'histoire du pays. Croyant probablement qu'il pouvait imposer sans crainte d'être opposé son agenda politique, le gouvernement de Monsieur Stephen Harper a manifestement mal joué la main qui lui avait été donnée. L'opposition s'est unie en opposition à l'énoncé économique du gouvernement.
En période de crise, attendue ou actuelle, il faut que le gouvernement soit prêt à faire face à toute éventualité. Ce n'est pas le cas du présent gouvernement.
La coalition de l'opposition, qui rassemble une proportion plus importante de citoyens canadiens que ce que peut compter le gouvernement, vous demandera de dissoudre la Chambre et de leur laisser former un gouvernement d'union nationale afin de faire face, dans l'immédiat, à la crise qui se profile.
Pouvons-nous douter, en de telles circonstances, de la nature démocratique de la démarche? Je ne le pense pas. Malgré la présence du Bloc Québécois, la coalition garde comme objectif le meilleur intérêt de l'ensemble du pays. Jusqu'à nouvel ordre, le Québec fait encore partie du Canada. Ceux qui excluent le Québec de la coalition sous seul prétexte que la province a choisi plus de députés bloquistes que les autres partis réagissent de façon ségérgationniste.
Je vous demande donc de considérer la demande de la coalition formée par l'opposition, démocratiquement élue par une large partie de la population. Je voudrais signifier à tous les lecteurs de ce message que pris individuellement, aucun de ces partis d'opposition n'a la prétention de prendre le pouvoir de quelque façon que ce soit. Mais si ces partis s'unissent, ils gagnent certainement un e certaine légitimité dans leur demande.
Merci.
Fidei Defensor
Québec
I'm sorry your work in Europe was cut short by the political manoeuvring going on here. I too would like to add my voice to those who believe there has got to be a better way to deal with - a; our economic crisis and b; our political troubles than a coalition government. I would rather go to the polls again than see a coalition, however legal and actually democratic but unproductive and divisive, form.
I also believe that if a second election should occur, more measures to see people out to the polls need to be taken. This year we saw the lowest voter turnout in Canadian history. With all due respect I would like to ask why that is. Perhaps it is because too many Canadians felt disenfranchised by the system, unheard by the government, and as though their votes would be as good as wasted if they did not cast them for one of the two main parties.
As someone who voted neither blue nor red; Tory or Grit, I saw exactly where my vote went, fool's hopes aside. There has got to be a better way, and it has to begin with a greater number of Canadians at the polls, making their voices heard.
It has always been my opinion that the parties of government should work together. A coalition government is my dream as it is the majority of representation working together to achieve a better outcome for Canadians. We know how Canadians voted and it is clear that only 38% are in favour of the Harper Government. How great is it if 62% are represented by a gov't united? That is what we should be trying for is unity and stimulating the economy for Canadians; not ignoring the issues and trying to look good in the face of economic breakdown. And how is it treason to come to an agreement with the Bloq? We are all Canadians and perhaps if the Bloq is listened to by the Coalition Gov't they will cooperate and it will bring the seperatists together with Canadians. Call me idealistic but I believe in this coaltion whole-heartedly. To spend another 280 million dollars on another election so soon would be so foolish. Spend the money on the needs of the citizens of Canada and allow a coalition gov't to carry on with business.
Thank you for you time.
Sincerely,
CaroleAnn
I write this as a very concerned Canadian,
That a Coalition government, assembled by soundly defeated parties, in our last election, including a separatist party, who's only goal is to break up our country, should even be considered is totally against the wishes of Canadians, as evidenced by voters, and is very unjust.
Please do not allow this to happen.
If no other options for letting our elected prime minister, Stephen Harper, continue in office is possible, let's have another election,
And I'm sure the defeated parties will be even more so.
Respectfully yours,
Fred & June Lyhne.
British Columbia
STOP THIS TREASON NOW!
I respectively request that you do not allow our elected minority goverment to be replaced by the proposed coalition. Please tell all the leaders to stop acting in their own self interest and put Canada FIRST!!!
I shall not write anymore but would like to refer your Excellency, & folks, who are reading this blog to go to the Dec 2/08 comment that was written by Linda Paolozzi, from Stittsville, ON. It is very well thought out and and very well written. Thank you Ms. Paolozzi.
On behalf of the Canadian people who took the time and effort to exercise their right to vote and re-elected the Progressive Conservatives and Steven Harper as our government, I respectfully request that you refuse the request by the three disgruntled parties to dissolve parliament and put the coalition group into power. The Liberals were soundly defeated and have a leader who is not even wishing to lead after May 2009. The New Democrats have not proven that they care for the welfare of the people. The Party Quebecois is more interested in separating from Canada, than anything else. How can we expect these three parties to possibly work toward the welfare of the Canadian public. To me they sound like a bunch of petty kids trying to circumvent the wishes of the people.
I was stunned when I heard that one of the reasons given for this non-confidence motion was the attempt by the Conservatives to remove the $1.95/head subsidy for political parties. I do not feel that it is right that my hard-earned income taxes (which are illegal in the first place) should be used for funding a political party. Let those who want to support a party pay for its existence. I certainly refuse to support the PQ since they don't even wish to be part of Canada, but gladly accept all the benefits that come with membership. Stephan Dion wants to raise taxes which is probably one of the main reasons he was defeated.
I respectfully ask that you not allow this coalition government to stand and give the Conservatives a chance to govern as they were elected to do by a majority of the people.
Sicerely
Bob Holicza
Kelowna, BC
Since you are not an elected individual and your job is a ceremonial one, you do not have a mandate from the people of Canada to make this decision. Therefore, if the Government is defeated, you must call another election, and let the people choose the government. You cannot allow a coalition which involves a party which wishes to break up Canada. We, and most Canadians, consider the Prime Minister to be the head of state in Canada, not the Queen or the Queen's representative.
In the last election, one of us voted Liberal and one voted Conservative.
I am writing to you as a very concerned citizen who has faithfully exercised her right to vote for the party I want to represent me in running our glorious country. I am horrified that a coalition of the 3 'losing' parties have decided the people's vote doesn't count if the voting doesn't go in their favour and are using the system to overrule the people's choice. Stephen Harper was voted in by the people of Canada to continue to run this country.The people clearly demonstrated they do not support Stephen Dion as Prime Minister. As a democracy, a coalition made up of the 3 losing parties does not represent the will of the people and should not be allowed to take power. I ask that if the government does fall because of a non-confidence vote, that you would allow the people to exercise their democratic right to vote again.
We are in danger of losing the thing that makes us Canada. Democracy. The right to a free vote and the right to have that vote be heard.
Thank you,
Mrs. Sheila Crowley
I cannot speak for the rest of the 62% of Canadians that did not vote for this Conservative minority in the past election, but I am sure they would agree that we would be very glad to see this Prime Minister replaced by parties that are more concerned with the well being of Canadians. The people have spoken with their apathy and hopelessness.
Our country does not want Steven Harper as Prime Minister but our current flawed voting system doesn't register the voices of all the other voters. In a sense, the combined votes of the rest of the few that came out to vote are just as democratic as the flawed "first past the post" system. I prefer a coalition that must regulate, mediate and cooperate with one another, than a single person that speaks for a very small minority of people. If I must cast another vote, I want all the votes to count, not just 37.63% of them.
I realize that never in history has a Governor General gone out on their own and not done what they are directed by the Prime Minister, but these are important times.
Sincerely,
Rob Hughes
Ottawa On
Governor General of Canada
Your Excellency
I am a quiet but proud Canadian.
I am appalled with the events unfolding on Ottawa. It upsets me to think that if this coalition government were to proceed as proposed, less than 23% of the population of Canada in the form of the Bloc, a party of Quebec Separatists, will hold minority control over all parliamentary decisions made in the next 18 months, if not longer.
This single-focused political party's mandate is to separate from Canada. How can we let them become the governing body? What legitimacy can this proposed coalition government have when it formally, eagerly and publically embraces the concept of Quebec Separation as part of its governing foundation? The National Government by definition rejects separatism. This proposed coalition government can be distinguished from historic precedent for it must put the interests of the Bloc, the Quebec Separatists, before the interests of Canada in order to govern.
If the question is put to you, I implore you to dissolve this Parliament and call a new election.
Regards,
Clare Morris, P. Eng.
We appreciate your timely return to our county in these exciting times, thank you!
Looking at the many comments of others being plainly scared of a coalition, I would like to give an opinion from another angle.
It is normal in Europe to have a coalition government, especially since they have a proportional voting system. Most European countries fare very well with this method of government. We have had a minority one-party government twice now whilst the majority of voters definitely voted for another choice in politics. Yes, the vote was split, but it would have been split for the right as well if there would have been more parties on the political right.
The paranoia of holding on to a one-party government at all cost is ridiculous and outdated. Finally some parties have the guts to leave the old adage behind and put their hands together forging a coalition. Will they do a good job? Of course they are not used to this, but they better catch on, otherwise we are back to square one. The parties in the coalition are undoubtedly aware of this, and we should give them a chance. The Conservatives had theirs already and blew it.
The lack of action of the current government to do something about the economy, while the rest of the world is fighting hard to rescue the situation, is a farce. The arrogance of this minority government to not cooperate with the opposition, after first telling us they would, is in fact undemocratic. If it were not such a dire situation we could put it on stage and have a good belly laugh about it.
I also sincerely hope for the initiation of a proportional voting system, that would give seats to parties like the Green Party, with their 900,000 votes. The system has obviously failed to truly represent the people. A Proportional voting system would enable the normalcy of coalitions, which would in effect cause more stability to build this country to a more modern state, on par with Europe. It would prevent extremes as having one government carefully build a health care system, educational system, equality in the workplace and then have a next government destroy this again going to another extreme. We need stability and it might sound strange but in effect coalitions cause more cooperation between different ideologies and can make a country more prosperous, self sustaining and well-educated.
Madame Governor-General, I do not envy your difficult position of having to make a decision on this, and fully trust your wisdom will prevail and I am looking forward to a new Canada, one way or another.
Sincerely,
Ellen Papenburg
Drayton
I am writing to you regarding the proposed coalition government of the Liberal and NDP parties, with support from the Bloc Quebecois. We have just exited a democratic election where the Conservatives won a legitimate mandate from the citizens of this country. The Liberal, NDP, and Bloc Quebecois parties did not run on a common platform, and the votes cast in the election were not based on that seemingly impossible premise. Our votes were cast in good faith on the independent policies all parties. However, with a hastily created, non-transparent agreement now in place with the Bloc, the Liberal and NDP parties have recanted on their independent policy platforms only weeks following the Federal election. If those parties topple the government and gain power, the good faith of the electorate will have been abused and democracy will have been distorted in Canada.
How can Federalist Liberal and NDP policies be combined with the policies of the Bloc Quebecois, a party whose platform includes promoting the separation of Quebec from Canada? What policies do those parties and the coalition now stand for? If they can change their policies overnight, how can we trust them to lead our country? Would our Federation be weakened and the cause of separatism be furthered by giving the Bloc the balance of power? These are very challenging questions and many Canadians would not have faith in such a fragmented and likely unstable government formed under such partisan political conditions.
At this point of great economic and growing political instability in our world, we need stability in government, guided by clear and unambiguous leadership. A coalition of parties with such disparate foundational policies and competing leadership agendas would create roadblocks and delays in setting priorities and making decisions. Such an unwieldy arrangement would send signal of instability to Canadians and the world. This would not be in the interest of our economy, our livelihoods in business and the public sector, the protection of our interests in the north, and our political stature around the world.
As the head of state for Canada, I implore you to consult extensively with constitutional law experts, other heads of state, and to listen to the will of the Canadian people. The population would rather face another election than be governed by a group of parties fueled more by political ambition than their interest in our country and the Canadian people. Please use the power entrusted in you to ensure the will of the people is not lost in this obvious political power struggle for the leadership of our great country. If the present government falls, please send us back to the polls.
Regards,
Stephen R. Saunders
Ottawa, Ontario